Typically it's in scum's favor to keep things hidden. If I kept anything from the town, it would be easy to mistake my motives for those of the cult.
Then why did you decide to mention these mistakes only after I questioned you regarding your meta? In your post here, you said that "I have made some mistakes that I sorely regret, and am having trouble rectifying them before anyone sees them". It sounds like you wanted to keep those mistakes hidden until I asked about them.
Well, it's true. I
want to keep them hidden, but they're already out there, just waiting to be seen. And I am trying to rectify them as quickly as possible by doing as much scum hunting as possible and answering questions as honestly as possible. But the fact remains that I made mistakes and anyone capable of performing a read of the thread can see them.
So why didn't I mention them earlier? I had thought you capable of reading what was there in front of you, but it seems you're just being fed information from your cult leader.
And another question, if you don't mind. Didn't it bother you, in the post in the spoiler,
flabort:
Is it OK that I'd rather not say? OK, OK, I'll spill; it would cause more harm than good at this point to keep it hidden. Hector13 got pretty close to the mark there with his accusations of trying to LOOK active but not being very contribution; mostly my mistakes were questions that didn't help at all and answers that barely made any coherent sense.
How would it have caused more "harm than good" to keep these mistakes hidden?
Typically it's in scum's favor to keep things hidden. If I kept anything from the town, it would be easy to mistake my motives for those of the cult. I'm not sure what you're trying to achieve by announcing your vote isn't going to stay on Saber, other than make Saber point out the scummy things that Fillipk has done, which isn't all that helpful to us in figuring out Saber's alignment because it gives him a pretty easy out.
Perhaps you were converted during N1? I'm looking forward to your analysis on fillipk.
I'd be more interested in his analysis of all the players.
that I didn't ask a question back to you? And secondly, didn't you notice that I had said "at this point"? There is always a time for townies to hide
something. ESPECIALLY power role townies, but not always. See also: Second spoiler.
Well either way, it is a form of scum hunting. Which I enjoy to see in players.
How is it scum hunting? It's akin to asking "do you have a power role?" which fillipk is still being scumread for!
And if that's not good enough for you, have your own words.
How does mentioning this idea help the town AT ALL? Obviously, anyone who thinks this idea could be right would have a power role, and anyone who confidently disagrees or asserts that it is impossible would just be a vanilla townie. This is information that the Cult Leader would love to hear. Discussing this idea brings NO benefit to the town whatsoever.
Like I said, it would cause more harm than good to keep that hidden then, so I revealed it at that time. A time for everything to be revealed, and because I was just watching Doctor Who and am feeling especially clever, a time to keep things hidden (Especially powers, of course). But I will reveal this next: I think I just found who I'll target with my power next,
Megggas.
Author
Topic: A Game of Clones: Game Over, Town-Cult Draw! (Read 51616 times)