Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[roo]

Easiest game of my life.

[hector13]

Dirty scummy bastards wanted to kill me  also thought I was jailor, which was rather amusing. I just wanted more from 4mask with that vote heh. Pressure votes are kind of awesome, apparently.

[origamiscienceguy]

The RNG left me with no other option 

[TheDarkStar]

Good game everyone. I guess it's a good thing that I switched to a TolyK vote at the end .

[TolyK]

Bah?
Very lucky game for town, which made us play extra-aggressive. I wouldn't have been gunning that much for ATH that badly if we actually had a kill N1... Though at certain points a was nearly convinced he was scum myself. >.<

Anyways GGWP.

[Shakerag]

PPE2: And that is the Shakerag I was expecting. I hope you realize that because you weren't being a sarcastic ass (meant in the nicest possible way of course ) that I thought you were up to something awful.

I was up to something awful!  Awful for the scumteam ... >_>

Honestly though, I was trying to keep a lower profile than usual because I really really really did not want to eat the N2 NK.

I do want to know if the ICs + Shakerag have any issue with how I was questioning OSG about his assumption and the 2/3 pages after it. I don't know if it I'm just being self-conscious or what, but during it I felt I was being quite anti-town with how hell bent I was on trying to get him the explain himself

Meh.  I've seen worse.  Might have gone a bit more smoothly if you had tried to re-frame the questions and tackle it from a different angle?  It did kind of feel like you were just banging your head on a wall.

Dirty scummy bastards wanted to kill me  also thought I was jailor, which was rather amusing. I just wanted more from 4mask with that vote heh. Pressure votes are kind of awesome, apparently.

Indeed.  I tend to liberally use them, along with a bullshit reason for voting said person.  Then you pay careful attention to how they react.

Good game everyone. I guess it's a good thing that I switched to a TolyK vote at the end .

MVP of the game here, folks.

OK! First 12 pages finished. Here are my thoughts so far...

Just from looking at the threat title, I already know that there is a jail keeper. I also know that ATH claims cop and claims he investigated someone last night.

i investigated tomasque it said he was town/notmafia

I find this situation highly unlikely for the following reason.

We know that the Jailkeeper and the scum must have voted for the same person. Under normal circumstances, there is a very low chance of this happening. I find it more likely that both of them voted for ATH (because of the Cop Claim) and he therefore survived. This poses on problem however, ATH wouldn't have been able to post an action if that were the case. Because he would have been jailed.

I haven't finished reading though, so I may have missed something blatant.

OSG I have to know.  Did you say you knew there was a jailkeeper here because you really extracted that from the thread title, or did you say that because you saw you got blocked in scumchat?


hector13, I think you can likely graduate from the beginner's games.
Megggas, if this was your first game, then you did pretty well. 
TolyK, get gud.  I was actually starting to question whether ATH could have been incompetent scum after a while because you were kind of insistent.  But then I looked at your posts and saw practically zero outgoing questions.  Technically that was half a pressure vote and half just a "I'm going to put my vote here for now until I can find something better to do with it" that just kind of lazily stretched the whole day. 
OSG, I think there were more opportunities to give out advice than you thought there were.  Even late into the game.

If anyone has any specific questions about play/posts in this game, or questions in general I'll field them as best as I can.

[origamiscienceguy]

I was at school when I replaced in, my school blocks quicktopic, so I had no idea there was a jailer.

Also, I didn't know how to IC at all, but I think I have a better idea now.

[TolyK]

The ATH focusing is definitely not my playstyle - it was initially due to a sudden lack of time, and later I kinda wanted to see how long I could get away with it (pretty long, actually, though it turned counterproductive).

Plus the only thing representative of my playstyle (scum or town) was not asking many questions. :p


Shakerag, it's really hard to read you due to you keeping many of your suspicions to yourself. :|

We thought Hector was scum due to him immediately attacking 4mask D2.

[Shakerag]

Shakerag, it's really hard to read you due to you keeping many of your suspicions to yourself. :|

Yeah, I was totally doing that on purpose this game.  Low profile, yeah?

[Megggas]

Any tips for how I can improve my play?

[origamiscienceguy]

I didn't really see any major flaws. I would recommend more games.

[NJW2000]

Sry, just got time to reply to this. That was fun, sorry about tunnelling Hector13, still think we should have lynched him, then OSG if hec was town, despite this being the worse option.

Btw, ATH/Mickey, the voice recognition thing is great, and you seem more flowing and expressive, very useful for mafia.

GG all, second BM out of two to end with only one town dead for me. Bit atrociously lucky, I guess, but fun.

I bet I'd have been taken in by OSG claiming jester.

[Shakerag]

Any tips for how I can improve my play?

Nothing glaringly bad stood out to me.  I'd say you just need more practice at this point.

Also, I'd recommend trimming down your quoted text a bit.  Seems like you were semi-often quoting huge blocks which made it hard to read through.

[AbstractTraitorHero]

Any tips for me to improve my play?

[origamiscienceguy]

Don't claim your power role unless you have good information to share.

I know it worked this time, but you got lucky punk . Next time, it probably won't end well.