Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[origamiscienceguy]

OMGUS much?

Why else would the scum not act TWICE IN A ROW?? Just so they can get the town to lynch one townie? I find that highly stupid if it is the case.

[AbstractTraitorHero]

Oh! It did. I'm stupid. Anyways, I am the Doctor, and I jailed Hector 2 nights in a row. So I think that Hector is the final scum.

I find it highly unlikely that the scum is someone else and they just "happened" to attack hector 2 nights in a row.

i inspected hector13 last night he was  town / not guilty.
So confirmed innocent (if I'm truly cop)
Tomasque
Hector13.

[origamiscienceguy]

Are you sure? You seemed very uncertain yesterday.

[AbstractTraitorHero]

 Yes I am the pm went through properly so I got my pm.

[origamiscienceguy]

OMGUS much?

Why else would the scum not act TWICE IN A ROW?? Just so they can get the town to lynch one townie? I find that highly stupid if it is the case.

Oh shit! I bet they were trying to get me to claim.

Oh well, there is only one left, it should be easy to find him.

[origamiscienceguy]

Unvote

Well, damn. I'm probably dead by tomorrow.

[hector13]

Anyway, ATH should have an investigation result. Who did you investigate?

My thought during the night were that ATH and Shakerag are town.

Shakerag voted Tolyk for most of D2, could've been a distancing thing but I don't think so.

Tolyk voted ATH most of D2, and I don't think he'd be voting his scum buddy all day.

I know I'm clear, NJW I'm inclined to say is n00b town... Megas has been quite townie throughout the game.

So my scum picks for today, in the order I want them lynched, are OSG and TDS.

I was voting for OSG at the end of the day on D2, why would I want to change that now? Not an OMGUS. Also, he got the name wrong for the role he was claiming. Silly scum

PPE: whose role claim are we believing, folks? If OSG is doctor jailor, ATH wouldn't be able to investigate me. OSG seems to have forgotten this...

[AbstractTraitorHero]

You wanna know what's funny?
That first scum he got lynched because he tunnled me?
So rodent that mean that my day 1 cop claim gambit actually worked becuase it made me an easy target so that scum kept trying to Lynch me so I did something so stupid day 1 but it worked out in the end and got scum lynched.

Okay if you believe im copthen that means that these people are innocent (alive people only)
Tomasque
Hector13
ATH
Yourself
So there's only 3 or 4 people who still could be Mafia.

Anyway, ATH should have an investigation result. Who did you investigate?

My thought during the night were that ATH and Shakerag are town.

Shakerag voted Tolyk for most of D2, could've been a distancing thing but I don't think so.

Tolyk voted ATH most of D2, and I don't think he'd be voting his scum buddy all day.

I know I'm clear, NJW I'm inclined to say is n00b town... Megas has been quite townie throughout the game.

So my scum picks for today, in the order I want them lynched, are OSG and TDS.

I was voting for OSG at the end of the day on D2, why would I want to change that now? Not an OMGUS. Also, he got the name wrong for the role he was claiming. Silly scum

PPE: whose role claim are we believing, folks? If OSG is doctor jailor, ATH wouldn't be able to investigate me. OSG seems to have forgotten this...

This

Oh! It did. I'm stupid. Anyways, I am the Doctor, and I jailed Hector 2 nights in a row. So I think that Hector is the final scum.

I find it highly unlikely that the scum is someone else and they just "happened" to attack hector 2 nights in a row.

i inspected hector13 last night he was  town / not guilty.
So confirmed innocent (if I'm truly cop)
Tomasque
Hector13.

[NJW2000]

Just saying, if OSG is speaking the truth, counterclaiming or denying would not be townie as an action, even to protect him. Because we've almost definitely found the other scum if he isn't lying.

Hector: how do you know there was no doctor/jailor? Or are you just being a bloody pedant again?


Let me see about this. If we're all not idiots here, if OSG is telling the truth, we lynch Hector as scum and probs win. If he's lying, we have 1 scum aaand 2 town the next day. I cannot see any reason for OSG to be lying town here, can anyone? I assume that if OSG is lying here, he's scum. If OSG is lying, therefore, we lynch him D4 and win.

Unless the scum targeted Hec two days in a row, and so did OSG as jailor. But I find that less likely, in terms of probablilty, I think, if nothing else.

Can anyone see a flaw in this reasoning? Have I misunderstood something?



PPE: 0h, right, maybe that's so, I guess they could've tried to lure him out. Still seems weird if they were trying to get a claim, odd stategy, yes, in that case, but I guess it explains ATH.

PPE#2:

PPE: whose role claim are we believing, folks? If OSG is doctor jailor, ATH wouldn't be able to investigate me. OSG seems to have forgotten this...

1. 1 Mafioso, 1 Mafia Role Cop, 5 Vanilla Townies, Sane Cop, Jailkeeper.

Tried reading the rules, Hec?

PPE#3: Ohmigodninjas; Looking at ATH's post, it's pretty clear that it's [me,] Meggas, or OSG. IF he's cop.

[AbstractTraitorHero]

Just saying, if OSG is speaking the truth, counterclaiming or denying would not be townie as an action, even to protect him. Because we've almost definitely found the other scum if he isn't lying.

Hector: how do you know there was no doctor/jailor? Or are you just being a bloody pedant again?


Let me see about this. If we're all not idiots here, if OSG is telling the truth, we lynch Hector as scum and probs win. If he's lying, we have 1 scum aaand 2 town the next day. I cannot see any reason for OSG to be lying town here, can anyone? I assume that if OSG is lying here, he's scum. If OSG is lying, therefore, we lynch him D4 and win.

Unless the scum targeted Hec two days in a row, and so did OSG as jailor. But I find that less likely, in terms of probablilty, I think, if nothing else.

Can anyone see a flaw in this reasoning? Have I misunderstood something?



PPE: 0h, right, maybe that's so, I guess they could've tried to lure him out. Still seems weird if they were trying to get a claim, odd stategy, yes, in that case, but I guess it explains ATH.

PPE#2:

PPE: whose role claim are we believing, folks? If OSG is doctor jailor, ATH wouldn't be able to investigate me. OSG seems to have forgotten this...

1. 1 Mafioso, 1 Mafia Role Cop, 5 Vanilla Townies, Sane Cop, Jailkeeper.

Tried reading the rules, Hec?

PPE#3: Ohmigodninjas; Looking at ATH's post, it's pretty clear that it's [me,] Meggas, or OSG. IF he's cop.

don't forget TDS (the dark star) he could also be mafia

[NJW2000]

Oh yeah. Weird having this many players D3, thanks. Gotta point out those lurkers temporarily less active people.

[AbstractTraitorHero]

Oh yeah. Weird having this many players D3, thanks. Gotta point out those lurkers temporarily less active people.

do you think me copclaimimg day 1 is what allowed us to catch tolyk day 2?

[NJW2000]

That would take.... more reading over than I should do at this time of night, but could well be. TolyK's play has been said to be flaky somewhere here, so I reckon a simple gambit might have got him into a difficult situation. COuld well be you.

[AbstractTraitorHero]

So Njw2000 who do you think is scum right now?

[NJW2000]

Jeez, going to have to read over. I don't think this has cleared Hector by any means, to be honest, and I find it odd myself that OSG didn't wait to see who posted before telling us all his role, it seemed careless. But I'm going to have to think and look hard to get good reads in this kerfuffle, and I don't have much time or mental energy now, I'm afraid... late. WHo do you think is scum, if you have time?