Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[DoctorMcTaalik]

Not Quoting the whole thing because I don't want to make this post too big.

I would be a hypocrite to argue that my day 1 mistakes don't matter as you have pointed out.  Yes I scum hunted lazily day 1, but then I have improved that on both day 2 and day 3 and the second half of day 1 after a little trial and error.  As to me not sticking my vote to one person long enough to have it mean anything, I cite my final vote on Roo, my vote on Moonlit day 2, that claim is quite a lie unless you only look at day 1.  I changed my vote a couple times on day 2 but both times it was when new information made someone scummier, and then cleared them up.

As to my apparent standard response all of those quotes are from a time period of two days.  All other times I defended myself with logic and reason and didn't mention my newness to the game.

@the Moonlit shadow exchange, I'm reading back through the thread and I realized two things, how bad the day 1 exchange looks on me and a couple things Moonlit posted that make them look really town.

hmmm this defense isn't making me look town, but then again your accusation is mostly based on my day 1 performance and my day 2 scum hunting and I don't know how to defend myself from this.

Well thanks for posting more, all your scum hunting, even though its on me, gives me the impression you are town.

I'm going to leave my vote on Teneb since I think he is the most likely to be scum even though he is requesting a replacement.  His first post has a hint of him being a werewolf as he wants to focus finding mafia.  His second post defends Dampe and tries to shut down speculation, which helps but I believe speculation can be used to decide who to pressure.

If I'm breaking a curtesy rule by not changing my vote please let me know

Fair enough. I'm still watching you, but that response was actually pretty well thought out.

Unvote.

Vote Dampe.

[fillipk]

Yes but it did almost nothing to make me look town, you had an extremely good case that I couldn't see a way to argue against except admit I was making myself look like scum, I mean I'm glad your not lynching me but I don't see how it was a good defense.

[flabort]

Can we get a vote count?

Now that I am home from a long and damp family reuinion, yes.

Votecount:
TheDarkStar
FallacyofUrist
Teneb - Fillipk, notquitethere
Varee
Arcvasti
Dampe - Tea, Varee, Arcvasti, DoctorMcTaalik
notquitethere
DoctorMcTaalik
Fillipk - TheDarkStar
Tea

Not Voting: Dampe, Fallacy of Urist, Teneb

Day ends Tuesday, 10:00 PM Mountain time, in 26 hours.

Dampe and Fallacy of Urist will be poked.

[Tea]

@Mod- Is there a reason that 'replacement needed' isn't in the subject? Did you miss or are you ignoring Arcvasti's question about which faction(s) was/were responsible for the Comrade kill?

[flabort]

@Mod- Is there a reason that 'replacement needed' isn't in the subject? Did you miss or are you ignoring Arcvasti's question about which faction(s) was/were responsible for the Comrade kill?

Re: Arcvasti's question:
Why was it unclear? He was beaten to death, he wasn't shredded or eaten. It was the mafia who did it.

I'm unaware of replacements being needed as-of-yet. I have issued a final warning to Dampe before putting him up for replacement, FoU got poked for activity, but isn't needed replacement right this second, and DoctorMcTaalik has become active since my poke on Friday.

[Tea]

Replacement Request. Sorry, but I am too stressed (and with too unstable a connection) to play mafia right now.

[Tea]

Though maybe we should just lynch him and save the eventual replacements for other slots idfk

[flabort]

Replacement Request. Sorry, but I am too stressed (and with too unstable a connection) to play mafia right now.

Sorry, yeah, didn't see that.
I'll put him up right away.

[Tea]

"Face deformed beyond recognition" read as p vague to me fwiw.

[fillipk]

So werewolves afked meaning Teneb Dampe werewolf looks pretty suspicious.

[notquitethere]

So it looks like we're collectively lining up on Dampe or Teneb for today. Those on the Dampe wagon, can you explain why we should lynch them today?

[Tea]

Honestly I was just waiting for the Daily Dampe this time with him being the biggest wagon before considering moving my vote back, but we're so close to deadline that I'm gonna Teneb. I will switch back to prevent NL obviously

[fillipk]

But tea that makes it a NL day.

[Arcvasti]

Those on the Dampe wagon, can you explain why we should lynch them today?

I'd say they're the most suspicious of the lurkers by a hairs breadth. Teneb was similarly suspicious but they had IRL stuff weighing them down, which inclines me to give them a bit of a break. How their replacement acts will cement my opinion of their scumminess. I don't believe Tea or Fillipk to be scum at the moment and we need to lynch SOMEONE or we'll get stuck in a rut. I would prefer to give them a chance to defend themselves before lynching them, however. For that reason, I am voting to Extend. An extension would give more people more time to react and potentially give us more information. And I honestly don't think that we have any better potential targets right now.

[Tea]

extend. @fillip I would rather someone else switch to Teneb but if not then I will go back to Dampe.