Toony:Supposedly it was a one-shot, though. You think that suffers from the same issue?
It was a one-shot because he killed and copied my role. 
How did you know this?
The best idea I can think of now is if somebody could inspect myself and 4maskwolf tonight. Nobody try to kill us. Well, you can kill me if you want, but don't try to kill 4maskwolf.
God damn it.
Unvote.4mask:I just realized IO asked me sommat.
IronyOwl: a multitude of reasons. One: by the time I actually realized the implications of ToonyMan trying to clear Cheeet, I was already convinced that Shamrock was mafia, and I didn't want to derail the lynch. Two: I didn't want him lynched so that I could stealify his role, because I hate being that vigilante who randomkills. And three, because if he was a mafia-ally I didn't want to tip him off too much that I was onto him: testing a theory sounds a lot less threatening than "you're a scum ally you scummy scum scum".
Why I've been ignoring it? I've not been. I missed the question and you never gave me a copy of it until now. I don't ignore questions.
How'd you miss it? It was right below the one you noticed.
Everyone who has voted for me: Explain to me, in concise terms, what the case you have on me is.
You're evasive and scheming, both at night and in explanation of yourself. You claimed that you showed up as scum to inspects only when it benefited you, kept incriminating information to yourself so you could murder the target instead of scumhunting them, ignored queries as to the reasoning behind your actions while answering different queries, and became prickly when pressured to boot.
So, it's time to take a little journey into speculation land!
Interesting. This doesn't explain very much if you're not scum, though.
Deus Asmoth:Deus:
Ironyowl: Tooney. He was doing his best to looks as scummy as possible towards the end of yesterday, which doesn't exactly fit into his claim of trying to get the scumteam to night kill him. Shamrock being scum points towards Tooney being flabort's new mafia ally, and while it's not the ideal lynch it's still better than not lynching him.
So... why vote him at the start of the day, then sit on it doing literally nothing, and only explain this now?
That bit about the deflation wasn't rhetorical, by the way. Why did you mind me lurking through the game, but weren't bothered by several people, yourself included, lurking through the day?
Because lurking throughout the game is worse than lurking throughout a single day? And of course, Tiruin had been questioned by two people beforehand which you had clearly noticed.
In what way? How would you rate Tiruin, DarkStar, and your own contributions to the game so far?
And my reasons for voting for Tooney were clear enough when I did it yesterday.
TooneyThat's some pretty bizarre reasoning. OSG turning out to be a member of the mafia doesn't negate what suspicion there was on BMC just because he had the most votes prior to the redirect.
Meaning?
My deeply hidden and difficult to discern meaning was that OSG turning out to be a member of the mafia doesn't negate what suspicion there was on BMC just because he had the most votes prior to the redirect and you acting as though it does seems bizarre to me. What's your opinion on Cheeetar's vote on Shakerag?
And you felt confident just sort of sitting on this for a vote until it went through, before switching to TDS because... you have no actual targets but lack the stones to just call for a nolynch outright?
Oh wait, Tiruin said something dumb. You actually suspect she may be scum or just trying to find ways to pass the time?
Shakerag:IronyOwl: Have you considered Lenglon as worth the effort of paying attention to yet?
Yes. Her mechanical analysis is not very impressive and I see almost no actual scumhunting. I don't like it.
I really don't want to blow another extend, so can we see some convictions come out?
Yeah.
However, why exclude Lenglon? Do you have a better read on her than you do Tiruin or Perseus?
IronyOwl - Basically Tiruin, but with a bit more town feel. However, since this is IronyOwl, I can't trust a town vibe from him, because experience.
This makes me feel warm and fuzzy.
Tiruin:Lenglon has thus far pursued and caught scum--given the context of her wording and situation, it was a vague and totally out of nowhere set, with all variables in play leaning neutral and which fully depended on how she played her wording; a mafia Bus is out of the question here.
She has?
...
Mm, 5th vote on BMC out of I think 7 cast, one of four people remaining on it until day end. First Shamrock vote, out of three remaining until lynch. Points for being the only one trying to lynch both BMC and his replacement all the way through, I suppose, though I'm not sure it speaks to her incredible scumhunting ability to bandwagon an easy target D1 and rebandwagon their replacement the next morning.
Cheeetar:My vote for ToonyMan was based on him getting stronger with the resurrect and the strong townread I've had on him. I'll note that my vote does nothing if his resurrect just fires by itself and doesn't make him stronger- however, if ToonyMan has been lying the entire time and doesn't have any resurrects remaining, he does die, and I think it's more likely that mafia would lie about that kind of thing. I'm leaving my vote on him until I have someone else to vote for (worst case scenario, he gets lynched and nothing happens, which is the same as me voting to not lynch anybody functionally.) Shakerag, are you willing to explain why I'm your top scumpick?
Ah, the ol' No Lynch. Favored tool of D1 noobs, desperate MYLO vets, bizarre hyper-specific power shenanigan warlocks, and absolutely no one else.
When you do predict a new lynch target will wander into your open yet stationary maw?
Author
Topic: BYOR 14 - Night 4: A Tie-ght Race (Read 77783 times)