Urist only had a brief tenure as militia captain of Mansionmurdered (
http://www.bay12forums.com/smf/index.php?topic=15096.msg1315947#msg1315947). Two years in, the human caravan walked into a goblin axeman ambush. As bits of of pack animals flew past their ears, my militia charged to the attack. Urist did surprisingly well, using my only masterwork steel axe to chop down three goblins. Then the last fleeing human merchant walked into another ambush, this time of goblin spearmen. Again my dwarves ran to the scene. Urist and my best axelord arrived first... and then a wandering Yeti distracted the rest of the squad coming up to support them.
The axelord was in a martial trance, acting as a little dwarven death machine. Urist managed one blow before being disarmed, thanks to a shattered right hand that DIDN'T HAVE A STEEL GAUNTLET ON. Before the rest of the squad could finish off the yeti and the last goblins, Urist took two spearthrusts to the chest, bruising both lungs. The civilians coming out to aid my wounded (i.e. Urist) were then interrupted by a couple of goblin snatchers... and by the time those were seen off, Urist had suffocated on the field of battle, and the recovery party turned into a burial party. All because Urist had (of course) forgotten to put on one vital piece of armor.
Oh, and the previous elven caravan were run off by skeletal muskox. Mansionmurdered is definitely not a pleasant place for traders to visit.