((Thank you for noticing that typo.))
Kikrik shouts a challenge and attacks! (13 vs AC) Miss...
He still shifts, though, because that doesn't require him to hit. The goblin also shifts, because it can do that when you guys don't hit.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
^.^..^..^...^^^^
.^....^e^^.^^^.^
................
..g...gG......a.
................
.....++++++.....
.....__E__+..Ad.
...cK++Y+++.....
........b.......
..g.............
.......g........
^^..^^^..^^^..^^
^^^^.^^...^^.^^.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
All the Cutters rush you at once!
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
^.^..^..^...^^^^
.^....^e^^.^^^.^
................
......gG......a.
................
.....+g++++.....
.....__E__+..Ad.
...cK++Y+++.....
...g.g..b.......
................
................
^^..^^^..^^^..^^
^^^^.^^...^^.^^.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Thankfully, they aren't smart enough to realize they aren't actually flanking Kikrik.
That's (20 and 16 vs AC) two misses against Kikrik, (12 vs AC) a miss against Ella, and (21 vs AC) another hit on Garrick, who takes 4 damage.
Now, Warrior E runs up to Garrick and swings, (12 vs AC) missing entirely.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
^.^..^..^...^^^^
.^....^.^^.^^^.^
.......e........
......gG......a.
................
.....+g++++.....
.....__E__+..Ad.
...cK++Y+++.....
...g.g..b.......
................
................
^^..^^^..^^^..^^
^^^^.^^...^^.^^.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Goblin Warrior D: 19
Garrick: 18
Goblin Blackblade B: 16
Yanlias: 16
Arti: 14
Goblin Blackblade A: 12
Goblin Warrior C: 11
Kikrik: 10
4 Goblin Cutters: 9
Goblin Warrior E: 7
Ella: 7
Goblin Warrior C: Marked (Kikrik)
Garrick: 8 damage
I honestly don't understand why all the monsters have higher hit bonuses than you guys. Then again, you have higher AC so it balances out I guess? I've used two different dice rollers so far, and neither have been favoring you...