Tiruin: No fallen angels. No new content in this game.
Umph, should be posting the above post-game due to personal speculation because I may pretty much be invoking possible emotional bias in readers (towards or against me/them).
Hooray just-woken-up need to post. -_-
*pokes you*
It's fine. Helps me understand your actions.
Working on a major post right now. Reads, along with model scumteams. I think I may be on to something quite useful.
I'm glad.
Ok, with only Roo left to counter-claim Cheetar's claim, I am pretty well forced to believe him. Since werebear has never been scum before... well, I guess it's not town-locked, but still... he wasn't fake claiming, which means in turn that the motivation behind his questions had nothing to do with a fake-claim. I am left with no case on cheeetar, so
Unvote.
NQT: My case on Cheetar was not me hunting a dangerous third party because I did not believe him to be a third party, I believe(d) him to be
Main-team scum that was pretending to be a town role that is very closely connected TO a dangerous third party. Him being the third party version never came into my considerations.
Your claim reminds me of the time that I was a sage in Super7... only, if I recall correctly, the sage doesn't get a choice as to what action they take; only that they are able to request flavor.
Here's an excerpt from my role PM from that game:
You will receive a new Clue each night relating to the factions working within the town.
It says nothing of a second ability, which your claim implies when you said "I studied both nights". This is strange, so I'm going to
FoS NQT. What could you/spruce have done instead? And why are you gaining information about third parties instead of the main scum team, anyways? Unless you already know everything there is about it.
Your suspects are me, Tiruin, and Roo, and given how you grouped us, you suspect Tiruin more than Roo. However, you FoS'd Roo and not Tiruin. How come?
Roo As long as he and a scum-mate are alive, assuming he's scum, then the scum-mate is capable of making the kill through them, or in other ways directing the entire team. If it's Tiruin or NQT, then of course they're capable of using him for the kill. Alternatively, the team could be
NQT-Tiruin, and not
Roo-Tiruin or
Roo NQT.
I must say that while I find NQT suspicious, their logic dictating me and Tiruin as prime suspects seems pretty sound. Given that Tiruin is more likely to be fake-claiming (due to not paying attention, as NQT pointed out) between the two of us, though (not saying one of us has to be), I find it odd that NQT doesn't even FoS Tiruin, let alone vote her over me; that sounds selfish, but it's true enough (I know the reason I'm being voted is over my cheeetar issue, though).
As far as the guardian angel goes, they are benign, yes, but they don't know if their protectee is town or not. If TDS being a GA confirmed Tiruin as benign, though, then logically I wouldn't have a reason to FoS her above, but I'm sure it doesn't.
I don't know what her alignment is - there are no flavortext clues and I have both an inspection-protection and a conversion-protection.
Not even TDS is sure.
I disagree with Tiruin about NQT's information about TDS confirming NQT as benign. Unless she's just saying that NQT's ROLE is confirmed, and not her alignment.
NQT and TDS back each other up; the Sage claim really reinforces the in-the-least benign nature of TDS, and it seems REALLY unreasonable that they'd be cult given all this (or malevolent third-party, ie reallybad fallen angel)
Uh... that's hard to tell whether she's saying NQT AND TDS are not-cult, or just TDS.
PPE: I just realized, after previewing, that I've mostly been pushing a NQT/Tiruin team in this post, and haven't been supporting my Roo case. So I've changed Roo's name to LightBlue and am now voting
Tiruin.