What I believe the cult we've got currently is a one-shot recruit
Why? Their team's kill's accounted for each night. We know they haven't recruited anyone, then, which I would think they would do N1.
So my guess is a Monster Hunter cultist.
...Aren't Guardian Angels a third-party goal focused on protection {any somebody} present?
You think the scumteam is a one-shot converter who hasn't converted and a bonus killer? Why?
And yes, Guardian Angels are that.
I'm basing my knowledge of cult on...well,
personal experience. While I did read someone mentioning a 'flavor cult' (which I guess is analogous to 'normal mafia but our name is cult instead'), I didn't think about it much at the time - and given my selective memory, prefer to defer to a more dangerous example at the moment if in case of most-dangerous-scenarios. I'm with the thought that there are ~3-2 cult. [2 being the latter if charismatic is present]
...Which means when I said Hunter-cultist, I was biased too by that memory, forgetting that monster hunters can pretty much be vigs. -.- Count this as a very late edit to what I said above.
But...how do we know if they haven't recruited? I'm sorta lost here (and lacking a bit of time to recheck back)
He's claimed a weak role that can't be easily confirmed that apparently one other person also has (not sure how common this is in Supernatural, games I skimmed never had two townies with the same roles).
Pretend you can't say 'neither' or 'I don't know'.
I love you
-r style of discussion.
Stop that. Affection makes me blush and develop rashes. (You're cool too.)
Wereteddybear.
PPE: Ohey this didn't actually post but I thought it did -_- Wheee.
Tiruin: Are you really a sexton? Give me some of your background.
I had to ask Meph for results of my anything and neither me or EPenguin got anything since ever. Because by that, I mean...my background doesn't have flavor.
Precisely, all I received was my duty and role. No background flavor or background identification (it's like one of the churchgoers being tapped by non-distinct out-of-scene narrative priest and handed a shovel and a line of string. Y'know, bell-ringer coffins and all. Or how I envision a Sexton anyway).
1. I want one of Tiruin or Flabort to either admit that they were lying and/or be lynched
o_O?
You...do know that if one of us was cult, we'd not do that because its pretty much against our wincon, aye?
I mean, even if I'm town, I could say I'm ok with being lynched if it removes the suspect list by a tiny bit, but while checking back and noticing the predicament of this situation quite thoroughly, I'm still standing by my logic back there about Flabort--yeah, he may be pretty much a bit anxious and neurotic when detailing a suspect down to the very details (I can relate at least, I'm like that x3 So much distress \o/), but when comparing claims--and while he didn't claim his claim thingy back when he claimed--I can't use that as a basis of delivery because it can be
extremely plausible that he's a Sexton, cult or not.
And yeah, the thought that he may be fakeclaiming did cross my mind too--but when that thought crossed my mind, I noticed I had already...unwittingly
claimed my results (I'm serious for not having read up back there, and apologies ahead, I thought I got the gist that 'Ohey massclaim' without even checking what others have said).
See: List sheet of the everyone claim (Jack claimed
Van Helsing that Hunter guy).
Now I'm not going to try to debunk your theory, because it makes sense from what others--I believe--may see as the most plausible. What I am going to debunk is the scope of said theory.
Primarily:
Off The Hook
Jack AT: As a Monster Hunter, he was killing Persus
TheDarkStar: Is confirmed as Guardian Angel by NQT (I can't believe anyone would fakeclaim GA out of the blue)
spruce/NQT: Studying
Weak Suspects
origamiscienceguy - OSG could have performed the kill IF the Werebear is an SK-style Werebear, but most likely scum would want to guard and kill in the same night which means the Werebear is probably a PGO-style werebear
roo: Has been completely absent for whole period. Could be a Werebear if Flabort is right, but I doubt it. Unlikely he'd be about to send in a kill either way.
Cheeetar: Claims werebear. Despite Flabort's argument, I think it's likely this isn't a fakeclaim. As such, he was busy killing OSG
Strong Suspects
flabort: Claims to be a Sexton.
Tiruin: Claims to be a Sexton.
Looking at the suspects like this, most likely either Flabort or Tiruin took the kill and I don't think both of them would be fakeclaiming unless they're a team (for reasons I'm about to explain). It's unlikely Cheet is fakeclaiming werebear, but it's possible he's an SK who targeted a protected player on N1. Either way, he didn't kill Birdy.
This lil' nyancat here.
I have to point out that we are lacking TWO players in this game
of thrones.
One of which was you...which we are unaware of the claim in particular (and may verily be bussing Flabort, if scum, and taking me as a safe drop because of my...utter lack, maybe. But that's predicting).
And the other is inactive--maybe because I guess he posts from his phone (and lacks a stable PC connection), and his phone is a bit :I
From what I know of Roo anyway.
Weak Suspects
origamiscienceguy - OSG could have performed the kill IF the Werebear is an SK-style Werebear, but most likely scum would want to guard and kill in the same night which means the Werebear is probably a PGO-style werebear
And just to nitpick myself, I wondered why you mentioned him as a suspect until I read you were checking the N2 kill.
In all seriousness, the Guard is like the Jailer...which I didn't figure out until I re-read the OP for the role-claim list, so even if its not somehow mentioned here, I agree.
And I've no idea why I'm saying that, but anyway--I believe you should broaden your 'who can kill' list to include roo, because even if he wasn't active, I do believe the scumteam may be able to submit actions for those who are inactive, if he's in league with them.
Right now, I'm torn between thinking the cult has three members or just two (with another malicious 3rd party. Given the persistent killing, I reckon they probably aren't a charisma cult, unless they're really biding their time).
(I really want to take a closer look at everyone, but it's late so this will all have to do for now.)
We're in the clear enough to not depend on that speculation as a whole, but as a note for later \o/
But query for you:
Who are you, Ser NQT?