Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Deus Asmoth]

OSG:I wouldn't have. The explanation is entirely WIFOM though. Why do you think that roo would be the target for conversion, since he's the most obvious target for protection as well?

Also, regarding your post at the end of yesterday, is it really suspicious that someone would be making a lot of posts about the cultist in a game where the cultist is the only scum? The fact that two of the posts you've highlighted are him giving some advice to a new player make me think you're trying to misrepresent him somewhat, so OSG.

[zombie urist]

No because he was pretty useless D1.

More later.

[Generally me]

OSG I woudnt have for the same reason as Deus. Its mostly because others woudnt know that I protected Roo so they wouldn't trust him. So in the end the known townie doesn't really matter after the first turn. Because it's possible he is a cultist, which puts him in the same boat as everyone else.

[TheDarkStar]

And I died on Day 1 again. I'll save further comments for the dead chat.

[TheDarkStar]

And I died on Day 1 again. I'll save further comments for the dead chat.

EBWOP: Bah.

[origamiscienceguy]

It just makes sense to me that he be jailed since that would keep him a known townie. But regardless, a suppose roo is no longer a guaranteed townie.

Im going to vote Taneb at least until he comes back on.

[roo]

zombie urist wazzaaaaap?


no clue why tds died lol. Who is the known townie? Or am I misreading? One every day right? And now we assume someone was converted.

[origamiscienceguy]

] The fact that two of the posts you've highlighted are him giving some advice to a new player make me think you're trying to misrepresent him somewhat.

I disagree. To me, it seems like he's testing the playing field in order to decide best how to approach everyone.

[Jack A T]

Who is the known townie? Or am I misreading? One every day right?

roo: Just a single known townie, just D1.

[roo]

man I feel like town is gonna lose. Cult recruit me. Ultimate wifom moment...

[origamiscienceguy]

man I feel like town is gonna lose. Cult recruit me. Ultimate wifom moment...

They did recruit you?

[Tiruin]

* Tiruin bops Jack

Net trubbles x_x
Still...2 pages? That's all the activity as of late?
Roo

man I feel like town is gonna lose. Cult recruit me. Ultimate wifom moment...

...Roo? Piece of advice--if you're serious here, you're not going to do well given that your allegiance to your team is with the cultists (and outing yourself generally ends in your lynch, overall). If you're town and trying to bait out the people in question (due to blatant wording)--then I'd posit a question to you:
How are you trying to help your CURRENT team with this level of interaction?

zombie urist wazzaaaaap?


no clue why tds died lol. Who is the known townie? Or am I misreading? One every day right? And now we assume someone was converted.

Err, what's the purpose of the orange portion?
And what were you thinking on the sentences after that?

On TDS: ...That vote on him was more on a placeholder as I got to speed with everyone else. Needless to say, net said otherwise -_-
Placeholder, because I've noted the point in TDS' idea being speculative, though not along the line of being subvertively speculative to hide or to detract from being cult.

OSG

man I feel like town is gonna lose. Cult recruit me. Ultimate wifom moment...

They did recruit you?

What's going on your mind as this is asked--other than return the obvious question?

Just so I can get an idea about how likely it is roo is still town, I would like everyone to answer this question.

Everyone, if you were the jailor, would you have protected roo? (be honest)

I myself would have.

Yes. But this is also depending on the D1 activity and what was being done--knowing my leads however, I would've gone with protecting Roo.
Question though: Your method seems...a bit unconventional. Look at the orange portion: How're you going to get that kind of idea when you're asking everyone -else- but the exact person in question? The person in the question of 'How likely this person is town'.
Peradon

My second scumchoice would be TDS. Besides his lurking, his last post felt like a lazy post and vote. He also asked me to explain myself, but has yet to respond to my explanation.

Your second scumchoice has your vote ever since Day end?
Compared to Teneb, how...valid do you actually think a 'last minute vote before day end' would actually help the Cult and act as a signifier in singling out the ONE cultist in D1?
Why was your second scumchoice holding your ONE vote?

[Jack A T]

* Tiruin bops Jack

Net trubbles x_x

* Jack is bopped

I understand.  Still going to prod when you hit the prod threshold, though.  Sorry.

[origamiscienceguy]

OSG

man I feel like town is gonna lose. Cult recruit me. Ultimate wifom moment...

They did recruit you?

What's going on your mind as this is asked--other than return the obvious question?

In my oppinion, what roo said here is absolutely stupid. If he is a cultist member, then he just possibly ruined the game for the cultist. If he's lying, then he could have just guaranteed his lynch which could ruin the game for the town. Either way, he's hurting whatever team he's on. I find it more likely that he was recruited and is unhappy with his team transition. I still won't vote 'till a bit later.

Just so I can get an idea about how likely it is roo is still town, I would like everyone to answer this question.

Everyone, if you were the jailor, would you have protected roo? (be honest)

I myself would have.

Yes. But this is also depending on the D1 activity and what was being done--knowing my leads however, I would've gone with protecting Roo.
Question though: Your method seems...a bit unconventional. Look at the orange portion: How're you going to get that kind of idea when you're asking everyone -else- but the exact person in question? The person in the question of 'How likely this person is town'.

The way I was thinking about it, if everyone said they would protect roo, then we could assume he was still town since the only people who had a reason to lie would be the scum, and they can't protect him. If some people said no, which happened, then there is no real downside.

[Tiruin]

The way I was thinking about it, if everyone said they would protect roo, then we could assume he was still town since the only people who had a reason to lie would be the scum, and they can't protect him. If some people said no, which happened, then there is no real downside.

...But you worded your question in a...more decentralized way.
As in, people are already putting that hypothetical that 'I'm the jailer and what would I do'. So it doesn't have that much of an impact that way.