I pointed them out earlier, and I'm too tired to go looking for them.
All of your "holes" were alternative proposals for situations, all of which ignoring Occam's Razor. They were all fringe situations that were far less likely than what I was proposing.
How was it ignoring Occam's Razor? Occam's Razor says that the scenario with the fewest assumptions is correct.
You assumed that both Tiruin and I were telling the truth. (2) You assumed Besmirch was what caused people to get a Guilty Conscience. (3) You assumed a townie wouldn't be the one to do it. (4)
You then assumed that everyone on the Peradon mislynch was clear. (7) You assumed flabort had UtV. (
You assumed (at that point) that DA was clear because he was voting, (9) and then assumed that left Persus. (10)
So fuck off with your 10 assumptions, all of which could easily be wrong.
I'm not blaming 4mask, just that his butthurt at everyone else for getting it wrong is stupid. He changed his vote to Perry with fuck all on him D1, and that caused a mislynch too. He's as much to blame for our current situation than anyone else.
I agree with this argument (cause I made the same argument yesterday), but I'd like to point that everyone on Peradon's lynch and Flabort having unable to vote are not assumptions because having guilty conscience makes it impossible for them to be on the lynch or unable to vote. Do you think 4maskwolf is scum because of this? In any case, using Occam's Razor at all in a mafia game isn't the best idea because it eliminates other scenarios that seem improbable (Webadicts BYOR comes to mind where we learned that instead of your standard scum team, the game was actually against 4 or 5 SKs, something no one predicted)
OSG:And you, Hector, seem to be immediately after a mislynch trying to find someone to blame.
Given that hector did not actually vote 4maskwolf, why are you accusing him of pushing for his lynch? And how would you know that 4maskwolf being lynched would result in a mislynch?
PPE:4maskwolf:flabort is guaranteed to have unable to vote, he proved it. Besmirch is the most likely option by any reckoning. If a townie did it then they are a horrible townie, which is also fairly obvious. The Peradon mislynch people are obviously clear you ass, they didn't die when he was lynched and it happened again D2. It comes down to between Deus Asmoth and Persus, and yes, I considered Persus more likely. That's THREE assumptions: That you and Tiruin were telling the truth, and that it's Persus over Deus Asmoth. You're either being oblivious as fuck or are scum, and I'm pretty damn sure it's the later, so have a vote. hector13.
Do have reasons for voting hector13 besides the fact that he disagrees with you? And saying besmirch is what happened is an assumption, albeit one that is a most likely. What do you think about TDS also having guilty conscience, where do you think he got that (He can't have gotten it from changelinged Tiruin because his vote was on Peradon)?
PPEx2:
My apologies for my outburst... that was uncalled for. I'm in a bad mood for a variety of reasons, most of which have nothing to do with mafia, but I snapped and that was bad.
I still stand by the essence of what I said though, which is that your argument is flawed.
Unvote then, you being upset explains all of your D3 posts so far. Sorry to hear you are in a bad mood, although playing Mafia might not be the best course of action while in a bad mood (although Mafia drunk is probably a worse decision)
OSG consider this vote in place of the FOS I gave you above.
Author
Topic: Choose-Your-Own-Mafias - Day 13: Unlucky For Some - SCUM B TEAM WIN (Read 109361 times)