Peradon: You're absolutely right, there was a human element to each of those tests. There is a human element to EVERY test. This is a GAME of the human element. You can't say "your tests are invalid" because there is some chance for a false positive, because a) it isn't a definitive test in any event and b) EVERY interaction test has a chance for a false positive. I don't know you. I don't know your metagame. I don't know how you play. So I have to make my tests as general as possible, so the chance of error is quite high. What you are missing is that those tests were just the icing on the cake of scumminess, and that all they did was tip you just ahead of TDS in my mind (whom you were barely behind). Your giving up when you are one vote behind is suspicious as hell, as OSG beat me to saying.
Did you actually read other games to see if Shakerag is normally that sarcastic? I don't know. Only you know that. I can't confirm or deny you doing that. All I have to go on in that regard is what you said about your unvote, which was basically "since you guys say that Shakerag is like that" without even the slightest hint that you had done your own research.
If you are town, I do sincerely apologize, and no matter your alignment I hope you don't hold it against me in the long run. I'm not normally this critical and aggressive: I reserve those aspects of me for mafia games.
PPE x2: OSG is providing good advice, although tunneling isn't necessarily a scum thing to do or a town thing to do. Toonyman and mastahcheese are both known for their use of the tunnel as both scum and town.
I'm also not saying "you're wrong" and leaving it at that. At this point, though, I'm not sure if you could convince me not to lynch you, because it's late in the day and at this point we need to see a lynch. In the end, even a town lynch provides the town with information, which they can then capitalize on in the upcoming days. This setup is also heavily townsided, so a town lynch is less detrimental than it might otherwise be. I'm not saying we can lynch with abandon, but I'm confident enough in you and TDS's scumminess that I'm going to push a lynch on one of the two of you today, even though there's a chance I could be wrong. Because that chance is always there, no matter the setup.