Note: Generally I see the uninformed majority as being socialism and the informed minority as being capitalism, just because of the way the game works.
But I think this set-up is very cool because it flips that concept on it's head; the scum/informed majority become socialism (sharing resources) and the town becomes capitalist.
So we're getting to reads lists today. Alright, I am with that. It's a shame NQT isn't playing to make a reads-aggregate analysis; I guess I'll have to do that.
Most ScumThe Dark Star: Man, I don't know how you managed to top the charts of so many people. My own reason for finding you scummy is first he leads us to believe he got changeling'd and lost his original powers
citation, but then took it back
citation (I could mention
this, but every one else already has). But his attack on OSG
citationcitation, which seemed very narrow minded (See also: tunneling
citation).
Shakerag: Still a joker/shakerag
citation. Missed my question to everyone, so I reasked it
citation, and his answer was
less than most; I felt I got more information from his joke answer to my joke question. Par for the course, I guess, as was the way he worded his vote on Peradon in the same post. I have mentioned before that I don't like the sarcasm
citation aspect of his meta, which sort of makes him one of my two always-scum reads. However, one thing that I can actually say is scummy and not part of his meta is tunneling
citation.
This post shows him exiting the tunnel, thoughPeradon: I guess he's active.
His interaction with hector at first seems odd, but is only natural considering they've played together. I can't figure why everyone keeps going back to the same "I was hoping you would answer that for me" buisness,
citation I don't remember if he answered my question
citation, even if it was an ultimately pointless question. I do understand the fact that people keep accusing him of asking how to play town
citation, since it's an easy thing to do by mistake. The thing that speaks to me is how he asks TDS why OSG was dodging the question
citation that he himself, peradon, had asked in the first place, indicating he was satisfied with the answer when TDS was not. His reaction to shakerag's hostile nature is also a lot like the first time I played with shakerag
citation, which isn't useful but lets me see his point of view better. I do have to say, though, that once he and shakerag clash he starts to tunnel a little
citation. I think his bad rep so far this game might be due to how often his name comes up.
Persus13: Only two meaningful posts.
First he adresses a poor case and a newbie, and asks some RVS questions, and
second he extends and does more or less the same thing. Nothing bad to go on, but so little to go on at all.
Tiruin: Do I want to believe her response to deathsword's answer to me?
citation Not really, but it's hard to tell. She has some speculation on powers
citationcitation, which does little, and little else
citationcitation.
Varee:
What feels like a trap? Honestly, I don't know. Varee is nice and active, engaged niceling in RVS
citationcitation, but the push for a no-lynch is odd
citationcitationcitationcitation. And lengthy, based on the number of citations.
Hector13: As pointed out by others, it's a little odd he asked about a specific power
citation, but more odd that he mentioned scum being limited with it. He's still a typical newbie
citation, willing to learn and all that but his posts are fluffy and insubstantial
citationcitation, a condition which I'm still guilty of from time to time. His new flaw
citation is almost convienient timing, if he were bussing before; but from a town perspective, it's just a really big pain. Neutral read.
Deus Asmoth: Nothing out of the ordinary. Maybe a clash with Peradon
citation, maybe some rather short posts
citationcitationcitation, but his early posts feel pretty normal and he admits that he is having trouble playing two games at once. Oh, yeah, and didn't know about the changeling being distributed; possibly due to a simple trait, which would explain TDS getting two copies.
4maskwolf: Second highest post-count. Jeeze, almost as many as OSG. He explains himself well, while being consise, which is a trait I admire
citation, but is only a meta trait. There's only a couple bad things I could say about him; he seems pretty determined to get TDS lynched
citation needed, his objection to Peradon's assessment
citation COULD be seen as a defense of Shakerag, and I guess at first I found it odd that he was voting TDS when Peradon was his top scumpick
citation, but I realized that it's just because TDS moved down on his list later.
Oragamiscienceguy: Hands down, the most posts in the game
citation. His theory on
Deathsword's death being to frame 4mask is quickly shut down, because honestly it's absured and almost impossible with the mask mechanic, but he admits he forgot it.
This seems to be one of his longer posts, an accusation of TDS.
In fact, with this post analysis (which 4mask had already analyzed TDS's votes), he looks like he's tunneling.
He gives a "too many variables" answer, which is just fine, to peradon and is attacked by TDS for it. I don't have enough time to go through every one of his posts, anyways, so I'm going to say a very, very slight town lean.
Most Town
Author
Topic: Choose-Your-Own-Mafias - Day 13: Unlucky For Some - SCUM B TEAM WIN (Read 109970 times)