DeusPisskop, what was the reason for the differences in your PMs? How did you decide who got which one?
I sent them at different times to different people with whom I'd varying levels of trust/interaction with. The differences between the two are the two questions.
CheetarEveryone: Don't just jump into the bandwagon because you feel obliged to be making a vote. Remember to actually play Mafia- examine if the person you're voting for is somebody you think is scummy, not just somebody that is agreeably scummy amongst the general playerbase.
[/b]
I am actually quite surprised with how quickly the DS wagon formed. I am interested to see his flip now, as a reference for this site. Keeing in mind that everyone has PM, including scums, I wonder how that will reflect . . .
Pisskop: You offered to post PMs of why you think Flabort is town. What does this have to do with me wanting to vote for you? (Also: Your strongly 'suspecting' that somebody is detective means nothing to us. Either somebody has claimed to you, or you're making it up. You have nothing to work off except what people have told you, and unless you want to say that I have no reason to believe there's a detective.)
Additionally: Why send different people different PMs?
Your response is one that suggests one of two things. I choose to believe you reacted in a relatively town way. As explained above, I sent out two waves of PMs, to people with which I enjoyed differing levels of communication.
Letting somebody live because they're a high priority target for a nightkill (assuming they're telling the truth) is not optimal, because it leaves open the possibility for scum to leave them alive to draw our suspicion to them, and they can also argue that they were left alive purely so scum would have an easy lynch the following day. At the time, I saw Flabort as the scummiest player, and I wasn't going to let his weird silly claim get in the way of my wanting to lynch him.
Are you opposed to giving him the chance to verify his claim? If you were scum and you believed flabort's claim, what would you do?
Be the one keeping him alive so I can whisper in his ear on who to kill to prove his towniness.
That only works if he thinks you yourself are town.
-Cheetar, why are/were you willing to compromise with a TDS lynch?