Pisskop, what was the reason for the differences in your PMs? How did you decide who got which one?
So, some reads:
Deathsword/???: Mostly reactive play, a couple of counter questions. My concern here is that his replacement request could have been a get out of jail free card in response to a growing wagon, but I'm not going to try get him lynched purely over that suspicion. Neutral until a new player takes over. I'll be interested to see what his replacement does, though.
Perseus: Same number of posts as Deathsword. Unlike Deathsword, he's had two pretty long posts and is willing to disagree with people, so probably not trying to lurk. Neutral until he gets some more posts in.
TDS: Also pretty inactive, but my problem here is that even in his longer posts he hasn't been doing much in the way of scumhunting. His last post was focussed entirely on supporting the flabort wagon and the ones before it were all very brief. Aside from his first post and one to UXLZ, all of his comments have been about that wagon.
UXLZ: By far the most active player today, and also scumhunting new people rather than following other votes. Probably town.
Cheeetar: Has too many 'e's in his name. Aside from that, he's been very active, answering questions, asking questions, revealing suspicious PMs, generally townlike play. I'm going to say he's town.
flabort: Still not sure that revealing Mask's gambit was in the town's best interest, but he's been active and participating. I don't think that he's scum, but third party is still an option. Could be a veteran hoping to lure in multiple night kills early in the game.
Jim: Is not M. Bison. I'm frankly unsure of what to make of him at the moment.
Mastahcheese: Voting for someone over a gut feeling is reasonable play on day one, I think. Him claiming that Scripten has been changing votes a lot after doing it twice is somewhat more suspicious. I'm leaning towards scum, slightly.
NQT: Reasonably active, a lot of content in most posts. I'm leaning town on him for now.
pisskop: Pretty erratic play, really. Could be an attempt to avoid a night kill after getting his role revealed on day 1, but the Deathsword PMs were questionable. I'm going for town or third party, I don't think he's on the scum team.
Tiruin: All of her reads were neutral or town. This concerns me. She also hasn't voted for anyone at all yet and most of her posts have been pretty short. I'm suspicious.
Everyone else: will be done tomorrow. I need to be up for work in five hours because I'm stupid and can't convince my brain to shut down in time to get eight hours of sleep :/