Reads4maskwolf The person I'd most like to have on my team if I were scum. Scum Bastard Mod, for sure.
TolyK The inconsistancies between my role and his result on me, esp. seeing me as mafia and not town or third party, are very odd. Also being the second cop to claim, at a time when I already suspected two other people of being cops (one claimed already), it's just too many cops. Yes, claiming earlier would have helped in my defense, but he's just... wrong.
Caz The evidence points to her being scum, but it also points at me, but I'm more inclined to trust the accuracy of Deus's claim. I don't like the "or something" in her brief role summary, though, and I don't like the way TolyK is being quite so agressive. There are four situations: 1) He's bussing her. 2) He's scum, she's town, he's trying to get rid of her. 3) She's scum, he's town. 4) There are two scumteams and they're both scum working against eachother.
Mastahcheese I only suspect him because of the convience of his claim for TolyK. And because he said he couldn't deny being on a team with TolyK and didn't raise an objection to it, although he could have been refering to being both town. (As a suggestion, how about a 6 on that scale?) If TolyK flips scum, I'd pressure Cheese a fair bit.
Persus13 8th rule of playing mafia: Don't comment on how much the night kill did or did not favor you first thing in the morning. Especially if it's the only thing you're going to say. Even if there is no kill, it often looks like scum patting themselves on the back for a clever play. This isn't why I suspect you. Despite the powers of observation I praised you for, you didn't answer the question in the post where I did.
Silthuri Usually absent. Drops by to bandwagon Scripten and Mastahcheese, then gone again.
Tiruin Usually absent. A few more posts than Silthuri but almost all of them are 'I'm reading'. One is 'I'm reading, but the cops are funny'.
Vivalas Newbie shields were up day 1, of course, but now they're down. However, I don't remember why some people found him scummy. I don't seem to be able to recall at ALL.
Deathsword I... didn't pay much attention to him. Null read because my fault.
TheDarkStar I... didn't pay much attention to him. Null read because my fault.
Comrade Shamrock I suspect he's a cop, but found town last night, so he's being quite. Either that or he was goading Deus into revealing himself, but I choose to believe the former because of his oddly specific questions. He doesn't like that I said it out loud. Oops?
Deus Asmoth Seems like a sane enough, trustworthy enough cop. The flavor contradiction is odd, but it seems more like of a case of Caz playing Monkey See, Monkey Do. I claimed miller, she claims miller. I claim a foreign nationality, she claims a foreign nationality. I claim a contradiction with the cop's flavor, she claims a contradiction with the cop's flavor. But as far as Deus goes, the leading theory is that he's sane and a victim of forgery.
Two cops is an issue, and there has to be something to counter that, and I'm worried that that something is a cult.
I once played in a game where litterally everyone was some form of cop. Insane cops, Paranoid cops, scum cops, role cops, insane or paranoid scum or role cops, etc.
However, despite this I don't think that there HAS to be something specifically to balance two cops; there might be two cops just because the mod wanted there to be, and he didn't balance it. So there doesn't HAVE to be something to balance it. Although there could be something, like a cult, framer, or dueling scum-teams as previously suggested, or some form of insanity. Not saying there HAS to be, though.
Persus, Re: Missed question:Shamrock ScriptenDeus
Mastahcheese TheDarkStar
Vivalas Flabort
Silthuri Tiruin
TolyK Caz
Deathsword Persus
For yourself, if you had an inspection, who in each column would you use it on first?
In each pairing, who would you rather be lookout?
Also, in each color set (colors are random), who would you like to be lynched the most?
Everyone:
Wouldn't Miller provide a reason for why you would show up as mafia?
Usually, if there's flavor as to who your are supposed to be (Such as a specific soldier), then there's a reason why you show up as mafia. Therefor, a miller should usually provide this flavor that explains it.