Well, since by my count I'm due to go unless there's a sudden upsurge in activity here, I might as well give some (slightly) updated reads.
Scintillant: Look at his reads and look at his play. His
only scumread is on me, the person he's voting for, and he hasn't bothered scumhunting anyone else. When asked who he thought was the other scum, he guessed that it's Mask, using the dubious justification that Mask hasn't interacted much with me and he hasn't done anything to follow up that suspicion. His reply here:
Other than the gut feeling, I didn't have much of a case against either of them after they addressed my concerns, so I unvoted. I view gut feeling as a reminder to keep them in the back of my head and pay more attention to their posts than I otherwise would. However, I don't see it as enough of a reason to keep a vote on them.
I've already told you that it's a speech habit that bleeds through to writing when I'm rushed, which I was when typing the response that seems to have made you decide I'm unwilling to commit to anything. It's also worth bearing in mind that that response was an answer to Dorsi asking me why I was acting over emotionally, which I didn't think I was. I don't see how anyone could be 100% certain about why they're making someone else think something.
Ok, I'll trust you on that.
is odd. According to the first part of the quote, he unvotes when the concerns he raised while voting have been addressed. According to the second part of his vote, the concerns that caused him to vote for me have been addressed, but no unvote and his read is as generic as he can manage. He only has a slight scum read on me, but he's not doing anything to investigate his suspicions. Everything he's done just makes me think he's waiting for someone to give him a wagon to jump on. Scummiest player in the game.
Dorsidwarf: Made a lot over perceived emotional outbursts on my part (that no one else agreed with, to the best of my knowledge). On the other hand, his arguments have been well reasoned as far as I can tell and he's not looking for a bandwagon, so I think he's town.
Scripten: Frankly, I'm conflicted about him. I think he's scum, but that may be coloured by our interaction at the beginning of day 2. He's very eager to discount any mistakes Scintillant has made, without offering an explanation (other than 'look at his day 2 play'). My options for him are three: I'm worse at this game than I hoped, he's worse at reading people than he thinks he is, or he's scum.
NQT: Hasn't been particularly active since before the weekend. I'm leaning towards town from his Thursday/Friday play.
Mask: Crusader was setting off a few red lights during Day 1. Wolf seems to be playing a towny but perhaps defensive game. This may be an attempt at damage control after Crusader's questionable play, so my read is neutral.
Author
Topic: Re: Beginner's Mafia #51: Alien Invasion - Town Wins! (Read 56391 times)