I wouldn't be surprised anyway, if he flipped town, I'd be more surprised if he actually did flip mafia. The lack of content makes it very hard to judge his alignment to any degree. I have currently unvoted him because a new suspicion has emerged. As to why I was voting him. I find his inactivity mildly scummy. I dislike his inactivity, especially in his role of IC and feel that if he makes it to Lylo it will screw us over.
This is not just due to his activity but the length of his posts. They leave very little to try and discern his alignment. His style is beneficial to him. Very little to read on and little questioning makes him an unlikely scum target as he's not that active. He mightn't be lynched for that same reason (If he continued to post small ones). Very little to go on which makes it hard to make a concrete case towards either town or mafia. He wouldn't have built much trust with any surviving town members, which might make his cases, even if right, ineffective.
This is a whole lot of fluff without much substance. You've repeated several points multiple times to pad out your arguments. To summarize:
- You think SBC's inactivity is mildly scummy.
- You think that his small, content-less posts will prevent him from being lynched.
- You think his cases will be ignored because of his inactivity.
While verbosity is not scummy, fluff definitely is. I will be keeping this in mind.
Scripten:
You are the one who started this SBC wagon. Yet you never saw fit to make a vote. You felt he was scum and wanted the rest of us to come up with reasons why. Fair enough, help the new players I guess. But you never extended it to anything beyond that. You offered speculation and encouragement but no direct involvement. Why? Are you trying to distance yourself from the lynch?
More misrepping. My vote was the first one on the SBC wagon. I didn't ask you to come up with reasons. I asked all of you to read through his posts and try to find something, anything, that suggested that his posts were at all pro-town.
Do you REALLY think I'm going to be distanced from SBC's lynch if it goes through? Come on, be honest.
Everyone: Superblackcat is probably scum. Note the difference between his play and Persus13's. Can everyone give me as in-depth a list as they can hack as to what SBC has contributed to the game?
This I feel is a leading question.
In the least rude way possible for me to say this, you are just wrong. This is not a leading question and I consider it disingenuous for you to present it as such.
This is a leading question and I don't like that.
You specifically quoted me here. Go back and look at the question I was referring to. Your question was as follows:
Scripten:
If you won't confront, are you at least going to ask questions?
Your question specifically accused me of being passive and not asking questions, which has been proven to be completely and utterly wrong.
My question does accuse SBC of being scum, but because of his lack of any pro-town contributions to the game state. I asked that question specifically to give the entire town a chance to prove me wrong. Instead of trying to do so, you instead attacked me for the question via dubious logic.
You led us straight to this lynch. You asked a question which heavily implied he was scum and basically told us to go lynch him. So what is it you don't like about leading questions? You asked one yourself. So now you are a hypocrite and what's more you didn't back it with your own vote. This could mean you either didn't have confidence in your own analysis, which begs the question. Why did you imply that we should definitely lynch him? Or it could be a scum strategy.
This entire quote is full of lies. I am voting SBC and have been for the majority of the game. I did not ask a leading question in the way that you are implying. If SBC flips town, my first scumread will be Comrade Shamrock due to his attempts to gain towncred via buddying up to SBC.