I'm not going to comment as IC on anything prior to my replacing in, but I will at request, or if something I think I need to comment on happens after this post- I'll probably do it in italics and a special colour and clearly label it as such. Everything else is just me trying to play to my win condition.
I'm perfectly okay with an SBC lynch, given his complete lack of content. However, it's not the best use of a lynch- I'd much rather he be modkilled or replaced or something. I'm going to use my time until the lynch scumhunting, rather than sitting and waiting for the flip.
Everyone: It is important to note that 3 people are voting for SBC purely because he's inactive. What will we learn from an SBC lynch beyond his role- has he had much interaction with other players?
masked_krusader: Your vote on SBC will remain there until he posts again. Do you believe he's faking an inability to post? Is your vote a 'punishment' for inactivity?
Deus Asmoth: You believed Execute to be more suspicious, and also lurking. Why then did you vote for SBC?
Comrade Shamrock: How will you react if SBC flips town? If he flips mafia? Would you unvote if SBC started posting again, and are you voting him because you believe his inactivity scummy or because you don't like his inactivity?
I do admit I did push you on an RVS but so did Scintillant. The exact same question in fact. I was not actually even trying to push a case on you at all. I know full well I don't have anything even remotely substantial. I'm just got a bad feel from your responses. It isn't very easy to put into words either. I was asked by Scintillant on who I thought was the scummiest.
This rubs me the complete wrong way. "I did a wrong thing, but so did this other person!" And then you say you weren't trying to push a case on somebody, as if this absolves your mistake. If you have a bad feeling from the way somebody is posting, you ought to be pushing and questioning them.
It seems as if you're playing in a very meek fashion,
Comrade- not the way I'd advise mafia to be played, and one which seems to indicate to me a desire to not be noticed too much. It's a scummy way of playing, and I'm going to keep my vote on you.
As you said yoursef, I'm making newbtown mistakes. And that's because I am newbtown.
You're clearly one of the more 'knowledgeable' players
Scintillant, and I don't think you should be playing off your mistakes as simply newness to mafia - mistakes often aren't scummy because it's more likely for new players to make them, they're scummy because it's more likely for scum to make them.
Author
Topic: Re: Beginner's Mafia #51: Alien Invasion - Town Wins! (Read 57440 times)