flabort: If it would help me achieve my wincon, yes. Which of your 14 RVS questions do you think will gain you useful information? Why? Of what sort? Which ones do you think will not?
Correction: 15 RVS questions.
Why did you feel the need to correct such a minor point?
I feel like out of all the players in this game Varee is the easiest for me to read.
I am very interested in this, since Varee has posted nothing but bull this entire game. What's your read?
Vector:
Cheeetar: Thanks for the answers.
Vector: To what extent is congeniality suspicious?
I see it as a sort of "entry scumtell." It's something worth commenting on and makes the person a worthy target of questioning, but not in and of itself worth hanging someone over. Similarly, so is unusual rudeness. I'm looking for variations from a baseline. I'm realizing now that the Mafia baseline level of aggression may have changed substantially since the last time I played.
What about thanking someone for simply answering? Is that not congenial?
Since Bay12 has moved away from "question one person during RVS" meta, I don't really have any way to "unvote," and "acknowledged" makes me sound wonkus. If I'm congenial, it's only for lack of better options.
Vector: It's been a while. How will Toaster's hammereriness affect your voting today?
Jack AT: Not at all. I may have to try to address more arguments to him vis-a-vis someone's scummitude or towniness, but it's not going to influence my vote.
Vector: I get the impression you put little thought into this. You would be as willing as normally to vote Toaster?
I don't tend to get good reads on Toaster D1, hence do not vote to kill him. If it were, say, D3, I might say something different; but right now, it really doesn't matter.
Everyone else What do you think about the accusation by Jim Groovester that TheDarkStar might only be pretending to scum hunt? Is it indicative of Jim's motives, or is it a well founded accusation?
I would believe it because none of TheDarkStar's arguments are really sticking in my mind, but I feel like this is at least the third time I've caught you crowd-sourcing your scumhunting. This feels like a town-dividing tactic to me. If you get a good response, we'll be at our throats arguing about the situation of your choice.
Vector:
What odds do you give to there being a cult in this game?
Reasonable, but only because it's the sort of thing I expect out of a Kill Whoever Now game. There's nothing in my role or that I've seen in play that would suggest the existence of a cult.
Vector:mastahcheese said you seem to be making yourself unsuspiscious. Why did you dodge the question? Do you think you yourself are doing this, and if not, what do you think made yourself suspicious to mastahcheese?
I'd need a quote for that, so I can understand what you're asking for. I haven't seen any statements from mastahcheese saying that I'm "making myself unsuspicious," let alone "making myself suspicious." If I've missed the question, it was purely by accident.
mastahcheese:You just outted a noble, potentially one of the strongest characters of the town side, for this little gambit because of RVS questions? Also potentially killing the hammerer. Neither of the outcomes would have been beneficial to town. What the hell man?
Why are you ascribing Jack AT's actions to mastahcheese? I strongly disagree with what mastahcheese did, but acting as though this were the
intended consequence seems like a bit of a reach.
I doubt the two of you are on the same side, but jegus, you're both incredibly scummy.
Vector Assuming you're town (or town-analog) in this situation, if there were two scum-team members left alive, as well as yourself and two other townies, which two players would you want to be the townie players?
Toaster and JimGroovester. They happen to be the two players who I would least want to be scum.
Everyone: Reads? I was going to ask specific people for their reads, but the list of people I wanted reads from grew and grew as I prepared my reads post.
1. Shakerag - Has been pretty light and bantery more than anything else, but he's asked a couple of incisive questions.
2. Cheetar - Asking good questions, but the "request the sole winner role" thing is rubbing me the wrong way. Other than that my gut read is town.
3. Jack A T - Not much of a read; he's been kind of low on my radar. Not drinking the WIFOM on the whole Noble thing.
4. GayArchae - needs to post
5. TheDarkStar - Dunno. I know he's posting, but nothing sticks in my mind from him. Under the radar.
6. Flabort - Too soft and leading the town too much. Not sure if nice/wishy-washy or just scum. Watching this one.
8. Varee - Lots of lolrandom stuff. Guessing he's a noob, though, not actual scum? Wish he'd focus.
9. Tiruin - Needs to post more
10. Jim Groovester - Don't have a good read on him. It could go either way. It's not for lack of posting; just don't know yet.
11. Toaster - Ditto to Jim Groovestar.
12. Persus13 - I feel like he's done a couple things that pinged me, but nothing big. Probably town?
13. 4maskwolf - Also a lot of shitposting. Not sure though, guessing town?
14. Mastahcheese - SCUM
15. SuperBlackCat - SCUUUUUUUUM FLIP-FLOPPY DREADFUL SCUM
Honestly, this would be a lot easier if I knew which alignments were even possible ._. If we're operating off of the two-parallel-games theory, then I can't say I'm having an easy time separating scumteams from each other.
Author
Topic: KYOSN: Now with Archived QuickTopic links! (Read 272451 times)