Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Worldmaster27]

Unless the "secret message" was the truth, and he's just kidding.

There's also possibility in that McDonald could be the role cop and not responsible for killing.

[Cptn Kaladin Anrizlokum]

Wouldn't the scum work together to kill each night? Making blocking one useless, because they both would need to be blocked. Why would you waste your block like that tn5421?
Sorry, computer being dumb, using French instead of symbols. Gotta go copy-paste question marks off Wikipedia.

So now we know -
Vanilla - My Name is Immaterial
Vanilla - Nerjin
Vanilla - The Dark Star
Vanilla - ÉÉÉ
Vanilla - ÉÉÉ
Vanilla/Jail-keeper - ÉÉÉ (Possibly tn5421, if it's the truth, which I doubt.)
Cop - Krevsin
Mafioso - Worldmaster (Maybe)
Mafia Cop - ÉÉÉ

Everyone, who do you think fits where on this list?
I'm going to do homework, will post my thoughts later.

[Worldmaster27]

Cptn: Why am I mafia? I'm going to assume you meant McDonald.

[Cptn Kaladin Anrizlokum]

Oops, yeah. Sorry.
McDonald is mafia, not Worldmaster.
Unvote, because I realized I wrote some names in red... Stupid colour coding ideas.

[Worldmaster27]

Cptn: So why aren't you voting McDonald? If you think he's mafia, vote him.

[Cptn Kaladin Anrizlokum]

Because I want to find the other scum today... If we can get the other then we win, because we know McDonald is. If we can't find the other, then I'll vote McDonald.

[Worldmaster27]

Cptn: Okay, that makes sense.

Especially if you're the other scum and you're just trying to delay the inevitable.

Why do you think you shouldn't just put your vote in for McDonald? You can change it if you want to, and I don't see why we'd prioritize one mafia scum over another.

Silthuri: You've been awfully quiet; what are you thinking?

[Cptn Kaladin Anrizlokum]

Okay, lets say we search for the other scum.
If we find them, we win the game because we know who the last scum is. the last day would have have two townies, and McDonald the known scum. That is pretty easy for town to win.
If we don't find them, then the last day has two townies, one scum. That is pretty dangerous I think. I would rather know who it is last day.

I would rather be left with a known value (McDonald) then not have any idea who the remaining scum is. Of course, if we don't find the second scum by the end of today, I'll vote McDonald so we still only have one to deal with. I'm keeping my vote free in case new information comes up.
I imagine the scum want us to end the day as soon as possible, because it leaves us with less time to hunt for the remaining one. Worldmaster, why do you want me to vote McDonald so much right now? We have nothing really to gain from voting him NOW. A vote elsewhere would apply pressure to that person, but he is already found out.

[McDonald]

I'd put tn5421 in vanilla/jailkeeper. I would trust her with my life!

[Cptn Kaladin Anrizlokum]

I'd put tn5421 in vanilla/jailkeeper. I would trust her with my life!

I can't take you seriously with your horse mask. And the fact that you are scum... this just made me laugh.

[McDonald]

I shouldn't have said that...

[McDonald]

Just forget what I said. Go back to your homework.

[Cptn Kaladin Anrizlokum]

Okay, McDonald. I'm not sure how deep you are going with this, but now you are trying to distance yourself from tn5421. It could be because you are trying to make us suspect him and he isn't a scum, or because you want us to think you are trying to make us suspect him and he is actually a scum. The problem is, both of those are good for you...

[Worldmaster27]

Cptn: Okay. I'm mostly eager to lynch scum, and I really don't see how leaving our votes on McDonald can hurt us. It could save us, even. In that, if two of the remaining town happen to be away ~1 hour from the day end but the two mafia are available, and we only have one vote on McDonald, the two scum could both vote for a town and lynch them, thus winning the game during the night.

Of course, that is unlikely, but I thought that Krevsin being a power role was unlikely too. Better safe than sorry, IMO.

PPE: _{Shh... he's screwing with us. Maybe.}

tn5: Anything to say? Do you think we should vote for him or not? And what's your response to what McDonald implied?

[tn5421]

I am town.  There is a strong chance that McDonald is also town.

McDonald didn't try to abuse that fact that I implied he was conftown, this makes me feel better about him.

I don't think we should vote him without a lot of discussion first.