Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Urist Imiknorris]

I've already explained why I believe Silthuri's claim over Toaster's. If you want me to do a better job of it, read the spoiler.

Spoiler (click to show/hide)

A survivor at this stage in the game doesn't particularly fear scum (who can use them to break LyLo) or town (who have bigger things to worry about), and are more likely to be forthcoming at this stage of the game. An SK would not want to claim survivor at this point as they'd be in deep shit when LyLo is broken/the real survivor is killed but the game doesn't end. They'd want to keep a low profile, and claiming survivor does not mesh with that goal. Silthuri sticks out like a sore thumb.

Meanwhile, Toaster was inspected by TolyK early on and had to explain both the third-party inspect and the roletheft rolecop. TolyK also gave him a particularly convenient fakeclaim when he accused him of being a survivor.

Additionally, didn't Silthuri claim that his votesteal was a night action?

And furthermore, there's one more angle to think of, considering I didn't block Toaster last night:

webadict: Do doctors know if they stop a kill? Do would-be victims know if they're protected?

[4maskwolf]

Sorry for poking in, but UI, Silthuri is a her.

[Cheeetar]

I don't necessarily think Toaster is a survivor, but I definitely am not voting for him even if he's an SK. We need the SK alive to win for now- he's going to magnet all the scum kills, and he wants scum dead just as much as we do.

Besides, let's put it this way:
Silthuri is survivor, and Toaster is SK.
That leaves 6 people, 3 of whom I am pretty near 100% sure are town-aligned. This means, uh... you're scum, UI. Sorry to have to break it to you in such a way.

[Urist Imiknorris]

EBWOP: One last note: Can we at least get complete night action info before you clowns hammer someone?

PPE: My bad, 4mask.

[Urist Imiknorris]

And another one!

Why do you think Nerjin's town?

[Cheeetar]

The mere fact that he's not jumping on the chance to lynch Silthuri is enough for me right now.

[Urist Imiknorris]

But Silthuri's claimed a revive. It'd be a waste of a mislynch for scum.

[webadict]

webadict: Do doctors know if they stop a kill? Do would-be victims know if they're protected?

When have I ever volunteered free information?

Never. The answer is never. So, no. They are not, unless an ability would do so.

[Cheeetar]

Okay, UI: What alignment do you think everyone is?

[Cheeetar]

But Silthuri's claimed a revive. It'd be a waste of a mislynch for scum.

Also note that he's yet to jump on the chance to lynch you.

[Urist Imiknorris]

I think Nerjin, TWS, and MBP are scum. This is a BYOR and as such is ruled by, as Jim put it, "unpredictable bullshit," so they're not revealing themselves in case town has an ability to fuck with their win. You, me, and Tiruin are town. Silthuri's a survivor. Toaster's the SK.

[Cheeetar]

Why'n the hell would two scum be able to hammer by themselves, and not hammer?

Also: Does this mean you'd be fine with a TWS lynch?

[Tiruin]

I'm good for UI or Silthuri, to be honest. Might actually be better to go for UI if Silthuri actually does have one of the claimed abilities.
Tiruin, Toaster, what are your thoughts?

Err...I'd recommend an extend because I'm seriously pondering the implications of many things on my side--stemming from one thing in question in my notes.

[Tiruin]

Oh, also I'm checking back on what stuffs I did earlier @PM list on whatpeople did.

[Cheeetar]

Extend. I promise we'll use this one, Webadict. Honest!