Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[webadict]

Also, if that was the case, why not make him a mafia-ally?  The role you gave him actually gave him a high chance of winning.

Okay, maybe mafia-ally would be a little too mean.  Fun for WIFOM, but little more.  Maybe the brother of one of the sk's?  So that they only win with a specific one.

Eh. I was expecting SKs to be lynched/killed more often.

[Urist Imiknorris]

Which is to say lynched/killed before endgame.

[Cheeetar]

What an incredible game. So sorry for lying about being your brother, Tiruin! Would everybody call me an even bigger liar if I said that I suspected there was more than one SK (didn't suspect anything on this level, of course.) I didn't want to say that because then everyone would know one of them was me. Also: it is amazing that all the SKs survived until the end. Shakerag must have been so beside himself. This is going to be a great deadchat.

Cheeetar is probably going to die today.
If he's the SK as expected, I'll be mighty surprised if he has any chance of winning.

Also- jesus, IronyOwl was correct about a lot.

[Tiruin]

What an incredible game. So sorry for lying about being your brother, Tiruin! Would everybody call me an even bigger liar if I said that I suspected there was more than one SK (didn't suspect anything on this level, of course.) I didn't want to say that because then everyone would know one of them was me. Also: it is amazing that all the SKs survived until the end. Shakerag must have been so beside himself. This is going to be a great deadchat.

Cheeetar is probably going to die today.
If he's the SK as expected, I'll be mighty surprised if he has any chance of winning.

Until Webadict spoiled it. In deadchat.

[webadict]

What an incredible game. So sorry for lying about being your brother, Tiruin! Would everybody call me an even bigger liar if I said that I suspected there was more than one SK (didn't suspect anything on this level, of course.) I didn't want to say that because then everyone would know one of them was me. Also: it is amazing that all the SKs survived until the end. Shakerag must have been so beside himself. This is going to be a great deadchat.

Cheeetar is probably going to die today.
If he's the SK as expected, I'll be mighty surprised if he has any chance of winning.

Until Webadict spoiled it. In deadchat.

It's not very fun to hold the secret of the whole game while watching, especially when it's hilarious.

[flabort]

...yes.
Unless it's even more fun to keep that secret.

[webadict]

...yes.
Unless it's even more fun to keep that secret.

The overall fun of watching is certainly more hilarious than the sudden WTF moment at the end.

[4maskwolf]

...yes.
Unless it's even more fun to keep that secret.

The overall fun of watching is certainly more hilarious than the sudden WTF moment at the end.

Agreed.

Actually, I had an interesting question to pose: should players who replace out for whatever reason be allowed to read and post in the deadchat on the grounds that they say nothing of their role?  They already have investment in the game and are effectively out of the game, much as dead players are.

[Cheeetar]

If they have the time to be engaged in the game via deadchat, they can probably afford the time to post as an actual player. It'd be super cool if people could sign up at the start of the game as 'spectators' and never be able to post or have a role but would know what the deadchat and mafiachats etc. were.

[Jack A T]

If they have the time to be engaged in the game via deadchat, they can probably afford the time to post as an actual player. It'd be super cool if people could sign up at the start of the game as 'spectators' and never be able to post or have a role but would know what the deadchat and mafiachats etc. were.

So, spoil specs?  We tend to avoid those, as they leave less interested players in the replacement pool.

[Cheeetar]

Ah. Reasonable enough- did not think about that.

[4maskwolf]

If they have the time to be engaged in the game via deadchat, they can probably afford the time to post as an actual player. It'd be super cool if people could sign up at the start of the game as 'spectators' and never be able to post or have a role but would know what the deadchat and mafiachats etc. were.

Sometimes people have to replace out for temporary reasons, such as overwhelming homework or surgery or whatnot, but are free later on.  They need to replace out so that they don't just leave people hanging for a week or whatever, but when they get back they don't have anything to do, but have investment in the game.

[notquitethere]

I could have done so much more with that role if I'd only lived. I liked the set up, the chances of town being nk'd every night instead of SKs was like a black turning up everytime on the roulette table...

[IronyOwl]

Oh man. This game.

[Nerjin]

I am rather annoyed right now. Like... Quite furious at how this went down. I'm not sure if it's the setup or just how it ended up happening. Bah... All I know is that I'm all played out on mafia for a while...

Good game everyone.

Except Puppet. Fuck puppet.

In the end my enjoyment of this game ranks above The Great Temple. So that's kinda nice.