Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[TolyK]

Reverie, I'm not against a Varee lynch per se, but I don't see it being too useful. By d2 the scum team will probably be in killing position, and we will know exactly as much as we do today. This is my only argument against a Varee lynch.

Reads next post.

[TolyK]

Going off the voting list here...

Reverie - Not all that much in terms of content that I remember. Seemed to be trying to take a neutral approach.
Tiruin - Seems town to me so far, hadn't done anything I've seen that was suspicious.
Toaster - Unreadable as usual. Seems to be doing his usual, and there's nothing I see fishy about him. Sure must be kept on him
Persus13 -
Varee - Had created an interesting neutralizer role, used it on the first person to vote him (credit not to me), opened up after being called out (and you can't say that he had to!), then engaged in newbish activities. Really seems to me like he's playing the newbie card inconspicuously. Would be good to kill at least once, but DATA.
Wolf - Seems slightly scummy to me, hasn't dispelled that sense. Has claimed a lot of abilities and seemed certain that scum won't target him for the several days he's building up.
Toony - Self-confident and slightly ballsy, but nothing really scummy. Can't recall any logical ideas from him, though.
Silthuri - Not much content, but now catching up. Null read.
Scripten - Nearly confirmed town and basically a vanilla player. Nothing else really stands out.
TolyK - Uses alien tactics and is strange overall. Must be scum.
Jiokuy - Not much content that stands out, though fairly active. Not much of a read (
null)
Flabort - Very picky, but that's all I can really say.

@Toaster: I'd he's super-saint and revives... Uh. I'd say that seems unlikely, but that would be VERY scummy on his part and he should be vigilante meat. On the plus side, we will get a flip...

[Varee]

Pfp
So one thing , i cant control whp am i hitting , masquarade did that for me

[TolyK]

Ebwodp:

Toaster: sure-> eye
Persus: Nothing pops to mind. Deathsword's replacement, which doesn't tell much either.

@varee exactly, which I'd why the coincidence is so interesting. Your scum buddy could've mask-inspected (peeked?)

[4maskwolf]

Wolf - Seems slightly scummy to me, hasn't dispelled that sense. Has claimed a lot of abilities and seemed certain that scum won't target him for the several days he's building up.

Not what I said.  What I said was that I'm using the anonymity of masks to keep me from getting screwed over by the scum.  Also: if you were scum, would you try and find out who I was to kill me, or would you attempt to kill off information roles who have a better chance of unmasking you (hah, yes, I get it.  I'm the MASKED wolf.  Very funny.)

[TolyK]

Yes, but you seem certain that you won't get hit either way, but that's not quite...

Look. 3 scum out of 12 players. Chances of not getting hit are multiplied each night since math works.
Disregarding lynches and revives, we get this (chance of surviving 2 days): 8/9*7/8=7/9=77%
Which means a 23% chance of dying, disregarding any other factors.
23% is pretty high for that.

[4maskwolf]

Yes, but you seem certain that you won't get hit either way, but that's not quite...

Look. 3 scum out of 12 players. Chances of not getting hit are multiplied each night since math works.
Disregarding lynches and revives, we get this (chance of surviving 2 days): 8/9*7/8=7/9=77%
Which means a 23% chance of dying, disregarding any other factors.
23% is pretty high for that.

But that chance is the same whether I claim or not is the point I'm trying to make.  Any role that has to ramp up power in order to work properly runs the same risk, but it's a risk I'm willing to take.

Plus, I can start graverobbing tomorrow if there are any casualties, so...

[4maskwolf]

TolyK, Persus13, and Scripten: You are the last three players with a vote who haven't used them.  Who do you think is a member of the scumteam?  Vote that person.  I know it's kind of hypocritical of me to say this, but remember that the vote is one of the town's most powerful weapons.  Use it wisely, but do not squander it.

Speaking of which, Toaster, what drove you to defend me from ToonyMan?

[Scripten]

TolyK, Persus13, and Scripten: You are the last three players with a vote who haven't used them.  Who do you think is a member of the scumteam?  Vote that person.  I know it's kind of hypocritical of me to say this, but remember that the vote is one of the town's most powerful weapons.  Use it wisely, but do not squander it.

Speaking of which, Toaster, what drove you to defend me from ToonyMan?

I'm still trying to decide if it's worth lynching Varee when he's got a confirmed resurrect. I feel rather stupid now for not preparing for a changeling attack, for if I hadn't added that, it wouldn't take two days of work to lynch him and get a flip.

Varee: If your changeling play hadn't been brought into the open, would you have claimed?

[Toaster]

TolyK:

@Toaster: I'd he's super-saint and revives... Uh. I'd say that seems unlikely, but that would be VERY scummy on his part and he should be vigilante meat. On the plus side, we will get a flip...

Oh, he's certainly scum if he has Super-Saint; there's no questioning it.  If there was any reason to believe he knew he would be getting a revive, I'd label him as scum straightaway.  Since it'd be rather hard for him to specifically target a revive, I can't label the Changeling Fiasco as anything other than a null tell.

I do have one question, though.


Varee:  Why did you target the Ultramarine mask?


4mask:

Speaking of which, Toaster, what drove you to defend me from ToonyMan?

I'm not.  I'm attacking crappy arguments, which I will do any time I damn well please.  Since he attacked me for the exact same reason, why would you think that?  Further, why is it okay when Tiruin defends Varee, even going so far as to extend to prevent his lynch?

[Tiruin]

I was wondering when someone would get to me :v
^{Also PFP, caught up with latest pages--giving reads soon (in 5 or so hours)}

[TolyK]

TolyK, Persus13, and Scripten: You are the last three players with a vote who haven't used them.  Who do you think is a member of the scumteam?  Vote that person.  I know it's kind of hypocritical of me to say this, but remember that the vote is one of the town's most powerful weapons.  Use it wisely, but do not squander it.

Almost definitely at least one of Varee, you (4mask), flabort.
Nah. I'm not sure I want everyone to know how many votes I have so far, and I don't see it changing any outcome that I'm not against. So, I'm using it wisely and not squandering it.

[ToonyMan]

PFP

If you don't vote I'm labeling you as nonvoter until proven otherwise. Covering it up now is only going to make you look even more scummy later.

[TolyK]

Gone with me - as far as you know, I don't have a self-cleanse to use.

[Reverie]

Gone with me - as far as you know, I don't have a self-cleanse to use.

Wait, you don't have a vote? Why didn't you just say this in the first place, Tolyk? You brushed aside your non-voting stance as just a personal decision earlier.