Ladies and gentlemen, Sappho's tutorial for how to tie huaraches without going between your toes!
1. Cut out the material. I used a thin sheet of leather from a secondhand leather jacket I bought for $5. Rubber tires are a popular option, and they give more protection, but offer less of a real "barefoot" experience. You should trace your foot loosely and leave up to a cm (or around half an inch) on every side. You can always trim it off later if you don't need it, and the laces will pull most of the material around your foot anyway, so don't worry about making them too big.
2. Stick your foot on there, center it where you want it, and poke your holes. There will be one hole on the outside of your big toe, one on the outside of your pinkie toe, and one on either side in the back, just in front of the ankle. Try to put the front holes closer to the tips of the toes if you can, since this will help hold the material and prevent it from flapping around if you've got thin leather like I have.
3. I poked my holes using a small hole puncher designed for paper. The holes were not nearly big enough for the laces, so I enlarged them by pushing a philips-head screwdriver from my pocket knife through there. Just right.
4. Time to tie. For laces, most people use paracord since it's very strong and durable, but I found it to be too heavy for the leather huaraches. Instead I tied together two shoelaces for each sandal and that worked great.
Tie a big knot at one end (so it doesn't get pulled through the hole) and push it through the big toe hole, from the outside going in.
Pull the lace across your toes and out the pinkie hole, then pull it tight and loop it around so it goes under the toe lace, from front to back.
Cross over your foot and head for the ankle hole on the opposite side, down through the hole, then back and threaded under the lace, heading back around your ankle. Use your finger to hold the lace just in front of your ankle as you pull it tight so you don't lose the slack you'll need later.
Around the heel (hold it up so it goes above the heel and holds on to your foot), through the hole on the other side, looped around and under the lace again.
Now you head for the front, for the spot in front of your ankle. Go under it, then pull it back towards the ankle.
Now you'll start a pattern. When you approach a hole, you go under the lace you're heading towards, then around and under the other lace. so it's under the front, loop, under the back - but above the new lace. Basically, you always go under the tight laces and over the loose ones you haven't pulled tight yet. This creates a strong pattern that holds the sandal well.
You'll go from this ankle back around the heel again, then back to the top of the foot, then back to the pinkie, then the big toe (you'll have to go through the hole here and loop around the outside of the sandal), then back to pinkie, top of foot, ankle, heel, ankle... until you run out of laces.
When you are about out of lacing, tie it off somewhere with a simple overhand knot and tuck the lace end in somewhere so it doesn't flop around when you walk.
And now you have your very own homemade huaraches! Go for a run!
You can slip them on and off by just pulling the laces behind the hell down to get your foot out.
Warning: Running barefoot (or with minimal/barefoot shoes/sandals) is different from running with running shoes. You'll figure out quickly that you can't take long strides or run heel to toe. This is only possible with the cushioning that running shoes give you - and this is what causes the overwhelming majority of running injuries. Your body was made to run with quick, short steps. You are never supposed to land on your heel or take long strides, or you'll mess up your ankles, knees, hips, and back. Barefoot runners almost never suffer injuries. So give it a try! You'll be amazed how much farther and faster you can run and how much healthier your body feels.
Let me know if any of you try making these. I want to see pics!