I thought victims of a flavor Cult disappeared?
Imperial Guardsman:You are accousting me for a random attack during RVS? is this actually serious?
When I see something odd I question it. I fail to see how Jack's not asking you a question to do with third-parties means he is a third party himself. Since I don't understand that leap plus you dived into the game attacking someone for something I don't understand and admitted you haven't been reading everything lead me to wonder if you were lazy scum. I've last seen you play well as town in Prince Mafia, but you didn't do as well in Round 3 as scum, so I felt your town game was better than your scum game, another reason you might have been lazy scum. I voted you because it would put pressure on you, and so you were more likely to notice my question, which you didn't answer. Now, why is Jack not asking about third-parties suspicious instead of oversight or focusing on going after the mafia/cult team we are facing?
I will take a guess and assume the Cult is the mafia team, and our SK is the Necromancer.
Long as it's a guess, don't take too much stock in D1 assumptions.
I thought the cultists were either stab, head chop, or CORE YOUR SOUL LIKE A FUCKING APPLE
Can you specify whether you mean flavor cult or converter cult? I always find it confusing when people don't specify.
Toaster:Imperial Guardsman:
Imperial Guardsman: Why would I specifically ask you? Why not, say, ask Tiruin about her most feared third party type?
It just seems suspicious to avoid asking about thirds IN A SETUP THAT HAS A STUPIDLY HIGH CHANCE OF THIRDS
How is that suspicious? Half of the players probably haven't mentioned third parties in their questions.
You and Jack's conversation is making me wonder if you just skimmed the thread looking for something scummy to attack someone on. I find that scummy.
You are accousting me for a random attack during RVS? is this actually serious?
And here you tip your hand; by questioning Jack's attack on you, you reveal that not only your attack on him is random, but probably also not even serious.
So why don't you clarify things for us? Who do you actually suspect, and why?
That's my attack on Imperial, not Jack's
4maskwolf:4maskwolf
Wolf
I think it is important that everyone talks, but not that I talk to everyone.
4mask: What's the scummiest thing you've seen so far?
Hmm... nothing really stands out right now
Well of course nothing's going to stand out if you don't press people. I'd like to see you talk with everyone so when you flip scum I can better root out your scum mates. Read the thread and use your imagination: what's the scummiest thing?
This bullshit here. NQT knows damn well that I don't like Day one, but he tries to get me to talk anyway. On top of that, he makes the assumption that I am scum, and it is a long leap from ignoring one question to being confirmed scum.
You're getting really mad at a D1 pressure vote? That is scummy.
Also, just because you don't like D1 doesn't mean you shouldn't talk. I don't like D1 all that much, but I tend to try and get as much information as possible out of it. Not talking in Day 1 doesn't solve the problem of no information, it just makes it worse. If everyone didn't talk D1, it would basically cause D2 to be a D1.
You forgot to link the game you personally ran in which I did basically nothing day 1 and then found the converter through process of elimination the following day. And as I am quite busy right now doing other things, no, I won't ask questions at the moment. Perhaps later today.
Yeah, but CYOM was extremely focused on roles and logic then just scumhunting. This game has some focus on roles and role powers, but the focus remains on scumhunting. Most mass-claims in this game type are usually D3 or D4, so process of elimination won't really work for you until then or later, assuming you aren't dead by then.
Mad? Point out where I am mad? Me calling it bullshit was calling a spade a spade.
I do talk on Day One. Otherwise I would be ignoring you all right now. However, in a game such as this, there isn't the massive time crunch that I felt in KotM, so I am content to observe Day One.
If something jumps out at me, I'll chase it. Otherwise, I will answer the questions of others without asking my own. I'm sorry if that bothers you all.
I was pointing out the CYOM thing in response to his using my RVS in GBU as an example for his point, not to say that I can repeat what I did in CYOM all over again.
You seemed to be overworked by the fact that NQT assumed you had scumbuddies, which is a common tactic to provoke a reaction, and one I've used myself. The flimsy nature of the evidence led to believe NQT was just trying to gauge your reaction and didn't actually believe you were scum. Your reaction seemed overblown because you started swearing, and took him much more seriously than I would have expected you to, making me wonder if you had something to hide.
I have played with you talking during D1, however, I do feel that getting as much info as possible is a good thing, especially since I haven't seen a Mafia game this active for a while. You asking questions is a good start, and you make a good point about Ottofar, something I might not have noticed if my pressing you hadn't caused you to point that out.
Notquitethere:Imperial, Tiruin, Zombie Urist, Jiokuy, Jim, Flabort
Everyone else has weighed in: what do you think of Wolf being lynched today? Are there good grounds or is it weak? Let's hear it.
To early to decide. D1 isn't even halfway over yet, and Jim, Tiruin, and Zombie Urist haven't contributed more than a few sentances.