I gave up both starting the Mafia DF Succession Game and listening to ER Talk 3 to do this post. I hope it's worth it.
Unvote Leafsnail. He's not the converter.
I didn't see a compilation of action claims, so here's one.
Tiruin: Free-Protect MOWE[Toaster] (Blatant), Inflate Kill
mastahcheese: D2: Sap Leafsnail, gain 8 points. Scan 4mask, result 1 point. Scan TDS, result 4 points.
4maskwolf: No actions
Jim Groovester: N1 Gift Leafsnail and Jack
Tack: Got Recycled
NativeForeigner: Fortune Teller
Objective: ---
MyOwnWorstEnemy[Toaster]: Trueinspect Leafsnail, returned Mafia
Deathsword[Persus13]: ---
Tawarochir: Santa'd Leafsnail
Jack A T: D1 Flavorinspect Tack (said to be consistent with his original claim); N1 Counted 4maskwolf (Blatant) - 1 power 2 autos; 4maskwolf agreed. Gained a power N1. D2 Flavorinspect TDS: consistent with his claim.
Leafsnail: N1 Recycle Tack, gain power. D2 Sap Tack, gain 7 points. Sapped D2.
TheDarkStar: Changelinged Objective (agreed by Objective)
Persus and
Objective: Claim your actions. If I missed them, my bad.
I totally disagree that Leafsnail wouldn't pull the recycle-sap combo as town. Since the scum team does not have a
group kill, nullifying the player who does have a kill/convert is almost as good as a kill. And if he misses, the townie still has reason and a vote. He's aggressive enough to take the risk- plus hey, more points for him. Good thing he can't buy Prolific any more.
4mask:
But seriously, did anyone even bother to read my idea of who to lynch?
Yes. It was terrible. You don't test lynch when there's a converter about.
So updating that list a bit:
Definitely Scum, but Not Converter:
Leafsnail [N1 convert most likely]
Objective
Probably Town:
Tiruin
Jim
Not Converter, most likely:
Tack [Recycled, which would have blocked him]
TheDarkStar [Changed with Objective]
Jack A T [Claimed logical-sounding flavor inspect on Tack D1; targeted 4maskwolf in the night]
mastahcheese [Can do three things in the day- no way could afford Convert as well. Nonvoter]
4maskwolf [Claimed kill with no counterclaim; Could have both but that's really unlikely; has two autos to go with converter- what would they be as scum? Nonvoter]
Possible converters:
NativeForeigner [Claimed Fortune Teller]
Persus13
Tawarochir
Why those three? It's possible there is a scum Fortune Teller, who gave the list to Converter Native to obfuscate his abilities.
Deathsword's claim is really weak, and there is absolutely no conformation of it in any way.
Tawarochir does claim two abilities that aren't claimed anywhere else, but if Native is scum it could have been edited that way. Leaf does counterclaim Tawa's claim, but Leaf is scum so that's not worth a lot.
So which one is it? I don't know for sure. I need to reread those three specifically but I'm out of mental energy for the night. (It's probably one of the latter two.)
I hate questions to everyone, but it's time for some.
Everyone: Who do you think is the converter, and why?
Both Leafsnail and I and TDS and Objective have hard-counterclaimed each other. That means one of each pairing is scum. Who do you think it is for each pair?
Also, Leafsnail has claimed one gift. Both Tawa and Jim have claimed giving him one. No one seems concerned about this. Why?
I agree with Jim that
mastahcheese should pick up Free-Recycle and use that to start mass-nuking potential converters if we fail to lynch the correct one, and Objective/Leafsnail if we do correctly lynch. Not Prolific Kill because Leafsnail will just recycle you.