That's called 'covering bases'. I said what happens if I'm right, I said what happens if I'm wrong.
You see, what truly baffles me when I think about it is- cops are the biggest threat to a scum. So making a cop claim is the easiest way to get yourself killed.
But the only action which happened to me last night was your supposed recycle.
Yet you claimed it, and claimed town. Which baffles me.
Because there was only two things I can pull from this:
1. The mafia had a definite lock on someone who was a much bigger problem than I, and had to convert them and leave me be.
2. The mafia knew I was going to be taken care of.
Seeing as nobody else made day 1 claims and the scan and count are in the (supposed) hands of townies, I can think of no reason for the first to be true.
Therefore, going off whatever logic I can scrape together, it must be number 2. And as you yourself have stated:
"I want to draw kills to myself" makes no sense as a reason, giving the mafia the information just lets them make a more informed decision.
But in my post I had said:
As I'm obviously terrible at this game, I guess I'll just throw down my cards early. Easier than wasting a lynch.
I took Infallable alignment cop and Blatant. Which means I'll most likely now waste a kill.
Sounds like the mating cry of the pressure-voted noob. Which you'd know.
So, just adding up variables again- stands to reason that the mafia made an informed decision, decided I would be protected (us not knowing it was kill-only at that point), and therefore sent you to recycle me. At which point there would be no reason for me to be converted because, as you said, 'I'm pretty neutralized right now'
But then I threw a wrench in those plans by forcing you to claim. If you are the Recycler and you're scum, then claiming Townie Recycler is the most logical thing to do. Having a dispute on your claim would lead to much more suspicion coming down on you, but claiming townie recycler fits. It's a nice story, so everyone goes along with it, albeit slightly irritated.
The logic further fits together with the idea of a scumteam which we put together:
1. Convert
2. Recycle/Sap
3. Changeling/Cleanse
So,
Leafsnail, those are my arguments as to why I believe you are scum. This time with at least 80% less OMGUS.
But don't cry, because if you get lynched and in the crazily unlikely event, show up Townie;
1. Your spare points won't have gone to waste.
2. This post:
Tack: Why do you think the recycler is scum?
I'd think a recycler is scum, since he targeted the guy who claimed a very town role.
Seems like a push from The Dark Star, another one of my 'big three', and a very cleverly made call by someone who would know we were both legit.
3. One less recycler to go to the enemy converter.
Oh, and there's still an infallible alignment cop running around on our side, so I'd really rather just lynch you now so that they don't need to waste their check on your scummy ass.
MILLER CLAIMS
4 false millers
Tiruin - Miller
mastahcheese - Miller
4maskwolf - Miller
Jim Groovester - Miller
Deathsword - Miller
Tawarochir - Miller
Jack A T - Miller
Leafsnail - Miller
TheDarkStar - Miller
2 Innocent
NativeForeigner - Not Miller
Objective - Not Miller
P-Luke - Not Miller - truth
MyOwnWorstEnemy - Not Miller
Tack - Not Miller
POWERS
Changeling
Convert
Count
Flavour Inspect
Fortune Teller
Hide
Inflate
Infallible Alignment Cop
Infallible Alignment Cop
Kill
Protect
Protect
Protect
Recycle
Santa
Santa
Sap
Sap
Sap
Scan
AUTOS
Bloodthirsty
Bloodthirsty
Bloodthirsty
Clear Minded
Clear Minded
Day
Day
Day
Day
Free
Free
Free
Immune to Night Kills
Innocent
Innocent
Prolific
Unstoppable
FLAWS
Blatant
Blatant
Blatant
Blatant
Dense
Dense
Dense
Hardcore
Hardcore
Hardcore
Hardcore
Magnetic
Magnetic
Magnetic
Mercenary
Miller
Miller
Miller
Miller
Miller
Unable to vote
Unable to vote