Games where the town plays horribly for most of the game but then somehow wins are my favourite
Limerick Mafia in a nutshell.
As for my first memorable game (reposted and rewritten):
Scum: TheDarkStar is scum!
Me: That's silly! I haven't even said anything yet! You're scum for leading a mislynch.
Everyone: TheDarkStar is just saying that because he's being voted for.
Me: Oh yeah, I can kill people.
Everyone: We're killing you for sure now.
(the game had an "expedition" system where the three or four people with the most votes were the ones who decided who among themselves died)
*TheDarkStar and three people who want him dead have gone, and the scummy guy has used his power to avoid having to go!*
TheDarkStar was met with an unfortunat accident! Suddenly, he shows up again!Me: Did I mention that I can survive being lynched? No? Oops! I'm still town and I can still kill someone. Lynch those scummy guys!
Everyone: WHY DID YOU NOT TELL US? NOW WE WILL KILL YOU
AGAIN!
Me: But I'm town!
TheDarkStar has been lynched! He was town!A townie has been killed! (by me)
Everyone: Well, he was right. Let's keep listening to the same people we were in the first place, especially since it's LyLo!
Another townie was mislynched!Another townie was killed by the scum!The town has lost. The guys that everyone listened to were scum, unsurprisingly.