Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Tiruin]

Unvote mastahcheese: I think you got rather defensive at my initial vote, however it is in line with how you act in other games. If killing the hammerer removes out ability to hammer, how does town win the game?

Whoever said that?

[flabort]

if the ability to hammer by votes is somehow lost, then since it's already been confirmed that a town win can be had with purely jailings, then we jail them. And since my awkward misinterpreting of the word 'flip' revealed that beating or jailing someone reveals their alignment, they can be used to hunt down scum, too.

[mastahcheese]

We already knew that they'd flip, though. It was in the OP.

[WhitiusOpus]

I have to agree with mastahcheese on this one, Imperial Guard is acting very suspicious, with the role-claiming he's been assuming. It just seems awfully suspicious.


Also, yes, mastahcheese, you count as experienced.

[Imperial Guardsman]

Imperial Guardsman: The scum already have an information advantage. I do not think it behooves us to puzzle out the different roles. It is unlikely the knowing roles will allow us to identify scum, and we would be giving up our only information advantage.

Im sorry about that, im speculating.

I have to agree with mastahcheese on this one, Imperial Guard is acting very suspicious, with the role-claiming he's been assuming. It just seems awfully suspicious.

How is this being suspicious?

This game has become insane (Not the mod's fault) why are people claiming? And subtly not-claiming that's really claiming? What the heck is wrong with you all? It's DAY 1 for crying out loud!
Imperial Guardsman, you're (like others have stated) just posting a bunch of speculation that serves no purpose, and then townclaiming, which is (as Caz stated above already) really freaking suspicious.
...And did you even answer my original question?
Vote Imperial Guard, he's either scum causing confusion, or being really bad town.

Which original question, and if you plan to hammer me, that is incredibly useless and takes a strong power role out of the game. If you jail or beat me, the Scum get the role. Contemplate this decision.

[4maskwolf]

Imperial Guardsman: The scum already have an information advantage. I do not think it behooves us to puzzle out the different roles. It is unlikely the knowing roles will allow us to identify scum, and we would be giving up our only information advantage.

Im sorry about that, im speculating.

I have to agree with mastahcheese on this one, Imperial Guard is acting very suspicious, with the role-claiming he's been assuming. It just seems awfully suspicious.

How is this being suspicious?

This game has become insane (Not the mod's fault) why are people claiming? And subtly not-claiming that's really claiming? What the heck is wrong with you all? It's DAY 1 for crying out loud!
Imperial Guardsman, you're (like others have stated) just posting a bunch of speculation that serves no purpose, and then townclaiming, which is (as Caz stated above already) really freaking suspicious.
...And did you even answer my original question?
Vote Imperial Guard, he's either scum causing confusion, or being really bad town.

Which original question, and if you plan to hammer me, that is incredibly useless and takes a strong power role out of the game. If you jail or beat me, the Scum get the role. Contemplate this decision.

Damn it people. A loyalty flip means that you reveal your loyalty, not change it.  How many times do I have to explain the standard mafia terminology.

[Caz]

Which original question, and if you plan to hammer me, that is incredibly useless and takes a strong power role out of the game. If you jail or beat me, the Scum get the role. Contemplate this decision.

Threatening that bad things will happen to the town if you are lynched is really defensive and scummy. Instead of doing that, give your own cases. Your effective argument atm is "Don't vote me, I am town" -_-

[4maskwolf]

A votecount:

Mastahcheese: 
Caz:
TheDarkStar: Imperial Guardsman, Tawarochir,
Persus13:
Tiruin:
Deathsword:
Imperial Guardsman: mastahcheese, Whitius Opus,
Tawarochir: TheDarkStar,
Flabort:
WhitiusOpus:
Jiokuy:
Superblackcat:
NoLynch:

Not voting: Caz, Persus13, Tiruin, Deathsword, Flabort, Superblackcat, Jiokuy,

Now, Q&A time:
What is the meaning of a loyalty flip?
A loyalty flip means that your loyalty is revealed to the general public
What happens if I loyalty flip scum?
Well, you're probably dead, in that case.
What does a twilight ability mean?
It means that you can use it during the twilight phase as or in addition to voting for the style of punishment.
If I use a twilight ability, does it interfere with my night ability?
No.  You may use one ability per phase, not per cycle.
Where do you get all of these questions?
Most of them I'm pulling out of my arse.  There are a few of them that have been asked various places.  For my next DF mafia game, I'm going to compile a list of Q&A from this game, as many of them may be more relevant to the next version.

[Tawa]

You know, your ganging up on Imperial Guardsman is a little suspicious too, mastahcheese.

You wouldn't happen to be a scummy traitor, trying to frame the Guardsman for your fiendish deeds, would you? I know of framing as a way for the Mafia to take out two townies in one day!

However, these are minor suspicions and my vote stays on DarkStar.

[Persus13]

Tawarochir

Why aren't you asking questions of people as if you are certain they're scum and off single pieces of evidence? and why are you voting Mastahcheese as opposed to WhitiusOpus?

Also, if you just switched your vote. If you want to say you're suspicious of Mastahcheese without voting him, put his name in blue.

Imperial Guardsman Reasoning on TDS vote?

[Tawa]

I'm following whatever leads I can find. Which aren't highly plentiful.

Also, thanks for the blue text bit.

Hm... good point on the WhitiusOpus thing. I'll look a few pages back and see to it.

[4maskwolf]

I'm following whatever leads I can find. Which aren't highly plentiful.

Also, thanks for the blue text bit.

Hm... good point on the WhitiusOpus thing. I'll look a few pages back and see to it.

Could you, for bookkeeping purposes, state who you are currently voting for in red?

[Imperial Guardsman]

Imperial Guardsman Reasoning on TDS vote?

Because pressure. Unvote TDS, mastahcheese

[Jiokuy]

Imperial Guardsman: I get that you are under a bit of pressure, but be very careful.
A) You changed your vote when asked to explain it.
B) Both your last vote and your current vote are the second++ vote on a player, which is usually seen as bandwagoning.
C) This is no longer RVS, just putting someones name in red has very little effect. Just voting without asking questions is a very easy way to mislynch.

Were I writing a guide to the Jester Role, I might replicate your actions :I.

In you favor, at least you are not lurking and only posting when directly prompted.

[Tawa]

Now that I look around, I agree with mastahcheese. VOTING IMPERIAL GUARDSMAN. I'm sorry for doubting you, Cromwell you cheese master cat you.

Also, I see that I was kind of stupid earlier. I'm sorry, Caz and Darkstar.