Time to pop up my search:
I'd agree on his behavior...Though he did state that he hasn't played an actual game yet and that this is his first game.
[2] Now let's check his pertinent posts sans faux-raeg at editing:
1,
2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7.
Now:
darkpaladin109
At #1 in that list: Why do you expect such a game to be 'chaotic'? What did you exactly mean by remaining 'cautious and hidden'? Because by recent judgement--that also pertains to active lurking and not posting. Not giving content or as much content that it would be trivial.
#3 = safety. However do note that Townies in any situation should discard that safety blanket and rely on their comrades-in-arms: you do not need to live to win, and if you live you need to act on the moral right of the Townie: Communication. If I am right in my judgement, this means that your play as 'cautious and hidden' SHOULD equal a cautious approach in this game, rather than active lurking, yes?
#4 points to the great time of Forum Database Down. The FDD happened to
everyone, and is not an excuse for lacking content.
Do note: You will be eaten alive if you continue this way. Mafia is about communication, in all their forms. Forum, IRC or Reality.
#6: I'd like to advance this note: What made you guess that said person 'could have been town' compared to quite anything else? Of that
note, you haven't addressed quite well anyone thus far-and, it would be said, that this is conducive as a detriment to any kind of role you hold.
Regarding replacements: As long as none have been announced by the moderator, you are still playing and it is imperative that you answer those questioned positioned towards you.
4maskHis current play seems to point at he has some sort of role. AKA not vanilla. His suspicion seems show a role that seems 'bad'. He doesn't seem like scum, because if he was, he'd have scum buddies helping him, and he wouldn't be showing so much scummy play. My conclusion is that he's a third party, Bad, because first of all. Bad sounds bad, thus the pressure, he's alone, thus not sure what to do.
Sans the speculation, that could speak about any such thing in Dark's attitude and not necessarily a role. Though yeah, upon re-reading it for a couple of times + tea, I could see that it could also pertain to him being able to do an ability...though it doesn't feel like that given the wording. His 'adequate job with my current role' speaks more along a generalism on how he values his own role.
Though I really can't get what you mean here. His play is...bad. Therefore, "Bad" because of the similarity in the word?
Also why would scum buddies help him in that context? The and he wouldn't be showing so much scummy play.
does help push an either third-party/Town note, I agree. But how would they help there?
My view on this, Tiruin, is fairly similar to that of SBC. He has said precious little throughout the game except things about being scared and trying to avoid attention. I don't think it is impossible that he is scum, but if he is, then it is likely that his scumbuddy is a lurker.
Really? How?