Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Elephant Parade]

@ToonyMan: I'm somewhat suspicious of NativeForeigner. Why? Because he wasted my extension. Sure, it might not have been deliberate, but I feel like it may have been a mafia ploy to reduce the number of extensions still available. I'm aware that this isn't the best reason, but I don't really have much else on either NF or SBC.

I'm kind of busy (semester finals) but the last one is Thursday. After that, I will be going over every single post and asking people some questions.

[NativeForeigner]

@ToonyMan: I'm somewhat suspicious of NativeForeigner. Why? Because he wasted my extension. Sure, it might not have been deliberate, but I feel like it may have been a mafia ploy to reduce the number of extensions still available. I'm aware that this isn't the best reason, but I don't really have much else on either NF or SBC.

I'm kind of busy (semester finals) but the last one is Thursday. After that, I will be going over every single post and asking people some questions.

I'll refer you to this post and the one immediately after.

[Elephant Parade]

@ToonyMan: I'm somewhat suspicious of NativeForeigner. Why? Because he wasted my extension. Sure, it might not have been deliberate, but I feel like it may have been a mafia ploy to reduce the number of extensions still available. I'm aware that this isn't the best reason, but I don't really have much else on either NF or SBC.

I'm kind of busy (semester finals) but the last one is Thursday. After that, I will be going over every single post and asking people some questions.

I'll refer you to this post and the one immediately after.

Wait, you didn't ask me to use my extension. Never mind. This is why I shouldn't play mafia at 9 PM.

[Superblackcat]

That is utterly ridiculous Superblackcat.  You're the other mafia.

What? Where's the evidence? What the hell are you talking about? And... Just plain what.

[Toaster]

Vote Count:

Elephant Parade: ToonyMan,
Superblackcat:
+!!scientist!!+: makeinu,
makeinu:
ToonyMan:
NativeForeigner:

No Lynch:

Not Voting: Elephant Parade, Superblackcat, +!!scientist!!+, NativeForeigner

Day 4 will last until Friday 1/31 at 11 PM EST.

Toaster: Does a specific member of mafia kill? Or does all of mafia kill? (So if X, Y , and Z is mafia, does X himself 'kill' (So if you block X, you block the kill) or does all 3 target the same target?)

It is a specific member, chosen by the mafia team, so your X Y Z example is correct.

[ToonyMan]

Scientist can't be a JOAT unless a town player is lying.  Why the shit would a town player be hiding their role still?

[makeinu]

Scientist can't be a JOAT unless a town player is lying.  Why the shit would a town player be hiding their role still?

I don't know, paranoia maybe? Bad play? Lurking? Though I don't give much credence to that, it's certainly a possibility.

Maybe they just have had terrible luck in target choices, and don't want to risk coming forward with nothing to report. Seems to be a theme in this game so far.

Or maybe I'm overthinking it. Probably am.

[Superblackcat]

I said, It's a possibility. The most obvious choice, is that it's just two people within the townies right?

But still, it is a possibility, and one I'm willing to consider.

But given how it is, and that if another person outs as a PR, scientist would most likely get slaughtered, I'm willing to think it's within the Townies.

[ToonyMan]

Which two townies are the mafia?

[Superblackcat]

FMPOV, it's gotta be 2 between makeinu, elephant, and NF. I'm more leaning for voting one of EP or NF.

[Toaster]

Everyone not named Superblackcat or ToonyMan has been prodded.

[NativeForeigner]

I'm going to be embarrassingly useless this day. Best I can do at the moment is reaffirm that I'm a vanilla townie.

For the time being, I'd like to hear scientists' speculation on why he's still alive today if he's the admitted jailkeeper.

I have the day off tomorrow. I'll reread a few choice pages and see if I can produce something useful.

[makeinu]

Everyone not named Superblackcat or ToonyMan has been prodded.

Ow... That was my eye. Emphasis on was. *dons eyepatch*

SBC: you provide, again, nothing really to support any argument. Meat, man, what the hey? You have to have a reason to suspect someone. Let's hear it, not just "I'm'a vote dat guy!"

NF: mechanics aside, I'm having a real problem with the fact that scientist lived last night as well. That says to me, if there's not another town power role, that scum are among the ones posting the least. Or Toaster's gone semi-bastard on us, and didn't follow the setup exactly.

scientist: why are you still alive?

[ToonyMan]

I'm pretty confident that Scientist is town so the mafia probably tried to kill me and failed.  Otherwise they didn't try to kill for some reason.

In summary though:

I think EP and SBC are the last mafia.  I don't really have the time to go over why completely, but I've made some points over the course of the game and also the only other player I can really suspect is NativeForeigner, who might be mafia, but might not too.

I would really appreciated it if everybody voted somebody.

[ToonyMan]

Day ends today?  Can somebody extend that has one left?  We can still lynch somebody today guys.