Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[makeinu]

Townie = specific role, town = town-aligned. War vet, Vigilante, Detective, etc. are all town roles.

Ah. Semantics, just not in the way I was thinking.

Yep, my words actually mean something.

As do mine. The distinction between Town, the alignment, and Townie, the role, is in the end irrelevant. Townies don't win or lose, Town does. So making a distinction between the two is a pointless semantics argument.

[TheDarkStar]

Townie = specific role, town = town-aligned. War vet, Vigilante, Detective, etc. are all town roles.

Ah. Semantics, just not in the way I was thinking.

Yep, my words actually mean something.

As do mine. The distinction between Town, the alignment, and Townie, the role, is in the end irrelevant. Townies don't win or lose, Town does. So making a distinction between the two is a pointless semantics argument.

Not really, since I see you haven't claimed that you are a townie, just town-aligned.

[makeinu]

Not really, since I see you haven't claimed that you are a townie, just town-aligned.

I'm really not getting into this with you. Seriously.

[Jim Groovester]

HEY THEDARKSTAR

DO YOU HAVE MYOPIA OR SOMETHING

IS THAT WHY YOU CANT SEE ANY OF MY POSTS

HERE LET ME HELP YOU BY WRITING IN ALL CAPS

NOW ANSWER MY FUCKING QUESTION

TheDarkStar, besides makeinu, who do you suspect?

[TheDarkStar]

HEY THEDARKSTAR

DO YOU HAVE MYOPIA OR SOMETHING

TheDarkStar, besides makeinu, who do you suspect?

Obviously, you didn't read.

Toaster.

[Jim Groovester]

Oh, good. You don't have myopia. You're just inattentive.

Anybody suspects besides those two?

And to clarify, your case on makeinu is because he has repeatedly claimed town, and your case on Toaster is that he is defending makeinu. Of course, you have opted to not respond to Toaster when he asked you to clarify how you are defending makeinu.

Clearly such things should be obvious from context alone, presumably.

Maybe you should consider being more responsive when you play this game.

[TheDarkStar]

Oh, good. You don't have myopia. You're just inattentive.

Anybody suspects besides those two?

And to clarify, your case on makeinu is because he has repeatedly claimed town, and your case on Toaster is that he is defending makeinu. Of course, you have opted to not respond to Toaster when he asked you to clarify how you are defending makeinu.

Clearly such things should be obvious from context alone, presumably.

Maybe you should consider being more responsive when you play this game.

I missed the first day of play, so of course I will be about a day behind in investigations. Why aren't you looking at Persus13, who hasn't voted for anyone?

Part of the reason I suspect Toaster is from earlier discussion (see the first thing on my wall of text [urlhttp://www.bay12forums.com/smf/index.php?topic=133676.msg4818927#msg4818927][/url]). Also, it doesn't make me trust a guy if he defends someone I already suspect.

Finally, note that it is not even night 1, so no one has very much true evidence yet. I can only do so much because the only information we have is based on what people say (which may or may not be true). While you can find out a a little bit, just about everyone is equally suspect here (since almost everyone is being voted for).

[Persus13]

I missed the first day of play, so of course I will be about a day behind in investigations. Why aren't you looking at Persus13, who hasn't voted for anyone?

First of, deflection, secondly, I've voted Max and Sinlessmoon.

[TheDarkStar]

I missed the first day of play, so of course I will be about a day behind in investigations. Why aren't you looking at Persus13, who hasn't voted for anyone?

First of, deflection, secondly, I've voted Max and Sinlessmoon.

Sorry, I missed your last vote change.

Do note that most of the current votes are for Sinlessmoon, who is not responding very much. This is not much better than no vote.

[Toaster]

TheDarkStar:

TheDarkStar:

I'd consider is reason to lynch if he came up as a townie based on the fact that, while he claims town, he carefully does not claim townie.

What does the first half of this sentence mean?  (Prior to the comma)

Hard to quote inline answers

How, exactly, am I defending Makeinu?

While you can find out a a little bit, just about everyone is equally suspect here (since almost everyone is being voted for).

How are the two bolded assertions related?

[TheDarkStar]

TheDarkStar:

TheDarkStar:

I'd consider is reason to lynch if he came up as a townie based on the fact that, while he claims town, he carefully does not claim townie.

What does the first half of this sentence mean?  (Prior to the comma)

Hard to quote inline answers

How, exactly, am I defending Makeinu?

While you can find out a a little bit, just about everyone is equally suspect here (since almost everyone is being voted for).

How are the two bolded assertions related?

I did not make myself clear. (Almost) everyone is equally suspected because everyone is suspected by one or two people. The votes (and the posts) are evidence supporting the statement that everyone is suspected roughly equally.

[Jim Groovester]

Why aren't you looking at Persus13, who hasn't voted for anyone?

Why do you care whether I look at Persus13?

This is also demonstrably untrue.

Finally, note that it is not even night 1, so no one has very much true evidence yet. I can only do so much because the only information we have is based on what people say (which may or may not be true). While you can find out a a little bit, just about everyone is equally suspect here (since almost everyone is being voted for).

This is not a productive attitude to hold.

You would be better off making the effort to find material on Day 1 regardless of your opinion on whether useful information can be found.

[Persus13]

TheDarkStar: Have you played Mafia before?

[Toaster]

TheDarkStar:

Hard to quote inline answers

How, exactly, am I defending Makeinu?

[Jim Groovester]

lololol myopia lololololol