Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  
Pages: [1] 2 3 4

Author Topic: Beginner's Mafia General Discussion  (Read 7017 times)

zombie urist

  • Bay Watcher
  • [NOT_LIVING]
    • View Profile
« Last Edit: November 27, 2013, 01:13:29 am by zombie urist »
Logged
The worst part of all of this is that Shakerag won.

zombie urist

  • Bay Watcher
  • [NOT_LIVING]
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia General Discussion
« Reply #1 on: November 19, 2013, 07:38:20 pm »

Why do BMs have only two ICs in play?

Since NQT's seen fit to mention the one currently in play I suppose I can too.

Week one we had total absence of IC Griffinpup, replaced after a week.  By that time we had absolute minimal interaction from the other IC, Deathsword.

Then Darvi, Griffinpup replacement was active for one week, with an almost total absence of the other IC for that week (1 post was made).

Then Darvi went silent again, for -two weeks- (save for a single oops post about forgetting the game at the end of the first week of silence).

We -need- to see normal play.  We newbies.  We need diversity and balance.

Has a BM consisting of around 40-60% experienced players been considered?  That way if one or another is 'distracted' or not as experienced as one might hope an IC is, if stuff comes up - there's more balance and flow.  Newbies have a greater chance of seeing effective playstyles, of seeing different things caught, of interacting with experienced players who are actually there to play and who actually care about the game - and those experienced players are not 'just' surrounded by newbies.

I'm in two other games with a far higher percentage of experienced players - no two experienced players are playing the same way.  Often everyone is making mistakes, misunderstanding things, people catch certain details but miss others, people think different things are Scummy.

I think BMs need more of that 'real balance'.  Do what you see fit with the extension rules or any other rules - but apparently people, -experienced people- some of them have trouble tracking vote counts.  Mods need to update frequently.  Mods need to follow the rules/expectations/guidelines set in the OP - if the OP says nights last for 24 hours - Don't set them to be 48 hours with no explanation.  Change whatever you think needs changing in the set up of the BM game - but what I think it needs MOST is the balance of a larger number of experienced players to the inexperienced ones.  And I feel that's a critical need.

The other half of the 'testing' that a BM does is give new players an idea if they like Mafia or not. It's one of the main reasons you get new players flaking at a higher rate than veteran players. Some people find that they just don't enjoy Mafia, don't have the time for it, can't handle the stress, whatever. And they bow out, usually never to return.

Not saying veteran players don't flake out as well, but generally they at least know that they enjoy the game and intend to go for the entire time.

So I agree that a Beginner game should have more built-in capability to deal with people dropping out than a standard Mafia game does. Whether that's a kill switch, a more robust replacement system, concrete rules for modkills of absent players, or something else. Been too long since I've run a BM, so I'm not sure which is best. Probably a combination. (Pretty sure I only ran the first one, though I've had beginners in a few of my normal games).

If the majority of players are going to be non-beginners, why bother even keeping the beginner format?  It would be easier to attract the massive number of ICs if it was a mod chosen setup rather than the same not particularly interesting semi-open/open one every time.

A cancel game vote would only make sense on a unanimous vote from the players (with absent players counted as voting in favour), otherwise the town can just vote to end the game if they get into an unfavourable situation.

Weird experimental idea: Pro-Am Mafia.  The setup requires 14 people - 7 beginners and 7 experienced players, but uses the Sprint setup.  Each beginner is paired with an experienced player, and the pair is then assigned a quicktopic and a playerslot.  Both players are then playing the same role.

The beginners all have a chance to talk about the game with their partner, and there's built in redundancy which should mean that playerslots don't fall silent when someone flakes.
Logged
The worst part of all of this is that Shakerag won.

Imp

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia General Discussion
« Reply #2 on: November 19, 2013, 07:40:55 pm »

Logged
For every trouble under the sun, there is an answer, or there is none.
If there is one, then seek until you find it.
If there is none, then never ever mind it.

zombie urist

  • Bay Watcher
  • [NOT_LIVING]
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia General Discussion
« Reply #3 on: November 19, 2013, 07:47:00 pm »

Also on the subject of ICs I think the quality of ICs really only started going down around BM40. I think Shakerag set a bad example by replacing out in BM39, but to be fair he have personal emergencies. In the future though ICs should probably realize that BM's take up to 1.5 months to complete and will require ~2 hours of participation a day.

I can't really fault anyone for not having that much time though.

Pro-Am mafia might work and someone should give it a try, but I worry about conflicting personalities. (esp since a few ppl on this subforum have pretty big egos)
Logged
The worst part of all of this is that Shakerag won.

Leafsnail

  • Bay Watcher
  • A single snail can make a world go extinct.
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia General Discussion
« Reply #4 on: November 19, 2013, 07:50:48 pm »

There could be some kind of Beginner Supremacy Clause where the Beginner has the final decision on the vote their slot makes.
Logged

Tiruin

  • Bay Watcher
  • Life is too short for worries
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia General Discussion
« Reply #5 on: November 19, 2013, 07:59:30 pm »

Also on the subject of ICs I think the quality of ICs really only started going down around BM40.
:(
I believe BMs should rather focus on teaching by fire and what to say rather than what to do--especially how Jim teaches. First teach the basics and the structure of how any general person can play, then take it off from there.

Pro-Am mafia might work and someone should give it a try, but I worry about conflicting personalities. (esp since a few ppl on this subforum have pretty big egos)
The concept of a team holds. Work together or perish alone.
« Last Edit: November 19, 2013, 08:01:26 pm by Tiruin »
Logged

Lenglon

  • Bay Watcher
  • Everyone cries, the question is what follows it.
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia General Discussion
« Reply #6 on: November 19, 2013, 08:29:25 pm »

Weird experimental idea: Pro-Am Mafia.  The setup requires 14 people - 7 beginners and 7 experienced players, but uses the Sprint setup.  Each beginner is paired with an experienced player, and the pair is then assigned a quicktopic and a playerslot.  Both players are then playing the same role.

The beginners all have a chance to talk about the game with their partner, and there's built in redundancy which should mean that playerslots don't fall silent when someone flakes.
I think this would become a lesson in frustration.
"Wait, who is X's partner again?"
"What did you mean by that?" "Well, my partner said it, not me, so I don't know the answer."
"So X wants to vote Y, but A (x's partner) wants to vote B"
14 players is a lot of people to keep track of.
Logged
((I don't think heating something that is right above us to a ridiculous degree is very smart. Worst case scenario we become +metal statues+. This is a finely crafted metal statue. It is encrusted with sharkmist and HMRC. On the item is an image of HMRC and Pancaek. Pancaek is laughing. The HMRC is melting. The artwork relates to the encasing of the HMRC in metal by Pancaek during the Mission of Many People.))

Leafsnail

  • Bay Watcher
  • A single snail can make a world go extinct.
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia General Discussion
« Reply #7 on: November 19, 2013, 08:37:03 pm »

"Wait, who is X's partner again?"
"So you're too stupid to read the OP or votecount posts, I take it."

"What did you mean by that?"
"Well you can clearly see that my partner said it and not me due to the fact he was posting from a different account.  I don't understand why you're even asking that.  However I can give you some insight due to the fact that we share a quicktopic."

"So X wants to vote Y, but A (x's partner) wants to vote B"
This is as much of a problem as mafia teams being divided on what action they want to do - it's a lot easier to make a decision if you know the other person is on your side.
Logged

Imp

  • Bay Watcher
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia General Discussion
« Reply #8 on: November 19, 2013, 09:06:47 pm »

7 -roles- sounds easier to keep track of than the 9 which BMs currently have.

A vote for either player is a vote on both players, because it's a vote for the role.

Someone says something you want to question, but you're not sure who their partner is?  Just ask that person.  Their partner should recognize their own partner's name and jump in if needed, as well as the targeted person answering as they please when they can.

A sample votecount post might look like this:

Player1/Player2:  Player7/Player8, Player11/Player12, Player3/Player4
Player3/Player4:
Player5/Player6:
Player7/Player8:  Player9/Player10, Player13/Player14, Player1/Player2
Player9/Player10:
Player11/Player12:
Player13/Player14:

Not voting:  Player5/Player6

As a recently brand new to Mafia player - I don't believe the pairing looks ANY more confusing than the original time I saw a real votecount.  I was confused originally, it got sorted out.  Exactly what a BM is about and for I think, and this isn't -that- much harder.  It's both more and less to keep straight, to my perception - equals out as different, not worse.

Edited to add:

This can be further helped by regular vote counts, all showing the paired names.

Difficulty in pairings by having the understanding that it's a 'newbie' game - if a pair cannot agree on some specific course of action at -all-, be that who to vote for or who to night kill or something not to talk about,  the OP will contain suggestions that the experienced player 'cooperate' with the newbie, so the newbie can learn through direct experience why the IC's suggestions might have been good ones, and TOO, if it's the newbie having a problem with their IC, allow the newbie to 'request replacement' for their personal IC - and for that IC to 'have to bow out' if their newbie wants them gone - unless the newbie's so crazy they try to do that then split....then let the IC back in and junk the newbie who's probably already disappeared I guess.

Unique problem players can be handled as unique problems?  But if the OP makes it clear that if there's a difference of decision, the pair should go with the newbie's choice if the pair cannot agree on the same choice, that will probably resolve most of those problems that may or may not occur, and the newbie is likely to quickly get information to realize that they were foolish (or smart) to not cooperate with their specific IC.

« Last Edit: November 19, 2013, 09:34:26 pm by Imp »
Logged
For every trouble under the sun, there is an answer, or there is none.
If there is one, then seek until you find it.
If there is none, then never ever mind it.

Toaster

  • Bay Watcher
  • Appliance
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia General Discussion
« Reply #9 on: November 19, 2013, 10:52:01 pm »

It's worth noting that a 7 player game with two scum is heavily scum sided.  Given that you'd suddenly have four people working together in a quicktopic plotting things out, it's even more so.

The only solution I could think of would be making two odd/even SKs, but that's not a simple game.
Logged
HMR stands for Hazardous Materials Requisition, not Horrible Massive Ruination, though I can understand how one could get confused.
God help us if we have to agree on pizza toppings at some point. There will be no survivors.

Shakerag

  • Bay Watcher
  • Just here for the schadenfreude.
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia General Discussion
« Reply #10 on: November 20, 2013, 01:13:40 am »

Also on the subject of ICs I think the quality of ICs really only started going down around BM40. I think Shakerag set a bad example by replacing out in BM39, but to be fair he have personal emergencies. In the future though ICs should probably realize that BM's take up to 1.5 months to complete and will require ~2 hours of participation a day.
Dude, what the hell.  How does replacing out because my mom was dying set a bad example?

zombie urist

  • Bay Watcher
  • [NOT_LIVING]
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia General Discussion
« Reply #11 on: November 20, 2013, 02:29:54 am »

Sorry dude, "bad example" was a poor choice of words. Replacing out in extreme cases due to unforeseeable circumstances is fine, but recently IC's have been replacing out when they shouldn't have signed up in the first place.
Logged
The worst part of all of this is that Shakerag won.

notquitethere

  • Bay Watcher
  • PIRATE
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia General Discussion
« Reply #12 on: November 20, 2013, 02:54:45 am »

Hmm. Most people know pretty quickly if mafia is for them or not, hence the high turnover of replacements in BMs. Education is on the job, anyone who plays mafia a few times will pick up all the basics. I think the main problem is game-fatigue in those that like the game in theory but in practice find it drags on too much. A set up with shorter days or, alternatively, fixed term days so the players know what they're letting themselves in for.
Logged

Jim Groovester

  • Bay Watcher
  • 1P
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia General Discussion
« Reply #13 on: November 20, 2013, 03:49:24 am »

So, what's the problem with Beginner's Mafias?

Before we start proposing solutions let's figure out what the problems are.
Logged
I understood nothing, contributed nothing, but still got to win, so good game everybody else.

notquitethere

  • Bay Watcher
  • PIRATE
    • View Profile
Re: Beginner's Mafia General Discussion
« Reply #14 on: November 20, 2013, 04:35:08 am »

I think they're too slow, which discourages new players. Mechanically they're not interesting to many experienced players (who might otherwise not mind playing with beginners), and though the replacement system is supposed to keep games well stocked with players, it typically doesn't and there isn't a good replacement-list-solution. Delaying games for long periods while the replacement list is populated is bad because new players typically want to play now and they might not have the same inclination a month later, yet starting a BM with few replacements is a recipe for absent players in the mid to late game.
Logged
Pages: [1] 2 3 4