...Meph: Isn't the theory of 'dual-roles on the same scumteam = no' equal a town tell for anyone else? Like NQT. It would be a glaring error to have 2 priests on a scumteam, so I guessed the best explanation is that there's a fakeclaim.
Precisely the reason I use a script for stuff like that. It balances stuff out, so if you managed to have, say, two Fortune Tellers on the same Scumteam it'd require a very powerful town to counter it. But it's quite possible. The script only restricts specific roles (like only 1 Vampire Lord total).
Two priests would be...risky for scum to use, since the chances of having two scum priests that would both res someone the way scum wants is very low. Still possible, though, depending on how everything else balances out.
Yeah. I got 'disagreed with' for stuff that makes no sense to me.
I had no problem with the idea that there could be two priests (or two anythings) on Scum team. NQT's insistent 'defense' that he had to be Town, in part because of the proof of there being a Scum priest - that gave NQT Scum points to me. Why is it impossible? How is it impossible? Was it ever said anywhere to be impossible? Nope to all - and here we're told that yeah, it is possible.
Though I had -no- idea that it was -Tiruin- and not NQT who was the cult converter, I did suspect and pretty loudly that they had one. If NQT had tried -less- hard to prove himself town by using 'non-facts' (we don't know who ressed Nerjin, we don't know if NQT is a priest, we don't know if NQT is also Scum and thus had access to knowing Caz was a priest - we don't know if NQT had reason to hide as one sort of converter by 'over-proof' of him being another sort of converter), well, if NQT hadn't been so intense about 'of course I am Town and only a fool wouldn't see that' - then I'd have had less of a problem.
Because wrong though I clearly am, NQT - your actions throughout did not look Town to me. Maybe I am the only one to blame for this, maybe the 'fault' is purely that Imp's to new to know what to look for or how to understand what she sees. But dang, NQT.
Meph, are you willing to confirm or deny that a Scum priest does have a chance to raise a dead Town as their previous alignment and role?
That's another thing NQT insisted on as a 'fact' that I don't see as being any sort of fact at all - it's solidly unproven.