@
Rolepgeek:
I had stopped it, as of post #69. You reopened it with post #102 and included it as one of two reasons why I earned your vote.
When I challenge someone's behavior, I want to see their response. You say 'stop it' when I respond to you.
Rephrasing to simplify my still unanswered question to you:
You wrote, directed at me, "Yeah, you're asking questions, and yeah, they're related to the game, but they don't actually help anyone."
Do you perceive all of my questions to be of the active-lurking sort?@
Kleril:
I screwed up and thought the vote Deathsword had placed was in fact a vote against him
Wow Kleril, voting and/or votecount format confused you too, and you just now see how it works? I think I had the exact same confusion! I asked about it
here and was answered
here. What did you think when you read the answer?
But if you only now understand how votecount works - but not before today - then every time you saw a votecount before today you read it backwards, right?
Votecount
Imp - kleril
kleril - Deathsword
Deathsword - Imp
You must have been very disturbed when you saw this one then, the very next votecount to be posted after I had voted Deathsword, he voted you, and you voted me. If you read the votecount as being reported backwards, that makes it all look really, really wrong! It looks like you are voting for Deathsword, he is voting for me, and I am voting for you.
Weren't you upset when you believed that the mod just summarily added you to the bandwagon that you had challenged me about joining, and made it look like I wasn't on that bandwagon at all? Did you feel any guilt or shame or anything that Deathsword's vote against you had somehow turned into your vote against him? Any anger or confusion that your vote against me had turned into my vote against you? Why didn't you say anything - everyone's votes must have looked totally messed up to you! You weren't even surprised that nobody else seemed to notice or care?
I don't believe anyone town will be trying to vote you off from this point forward, and this may be our downfall.
That sounds bad. Do you really think that in the future only Scum will vote for me? Should we use that as a way to find them? Do you mean that you think the person still voting for me is Scum? I feel like you're protecting me as best you can. Why do you think I should be protected - and who do you think your words are protecting me from?
@
Superblackcat:
Imp this one:
So, please answer the question, What do you think we should do today?
Gotcha! Talk to each other, especially the people who have not been as active in the thread. Griffinpup's replacement, if we get one, gotta check him or her out and see what he or she thinks about all this stuff. Attempt to scum hunt. When challenged about something, share our thinking so if we are not Scummy, the others who are concerned have a chance to better determine if what bothered them was Scummy or not. Before the end of day, I still believe we should be trying to lynch the Scum, if we can as most of a group agree on anyone to lynch that is. But I am still open to changing my mind, if you or anyone can convince me what productive thing to
DO while not lynching that's going to lead to a Town win.
What I think
you in particular should do for the rest of the day is make it really clear how your method of scum hunting is done. You gave us a very clear partial plan - vote no lynch today and tomorrow. But that doesn't feel at all like a complete plan to me, at least not one that leads to a Town victory. What are the missing pieces? Or are you already showing us? So far what I understand from what you show, you first defended yourself, then started asking everyone else who they thought were Scum and Town and asking what others thought should be done. I still don't hear 'plan for Town win' when I read your words. But surely you have one - you wouldn't advise sitting there like dumb ducks for two game days as a Town win method, would you? Really?
By the way... I'll point out too that saying things like
I was not able to read through most of the posts.
may not exactly support your Towniness either. I tentatively believe that Scum have little need to really Scumhunt (except to better appear to be Town) and that they are less motivated, not only to hunt themselves, but to really work very hard to follow others' attempts to Scumhunt - especially if those attempts are not directed towards themselves. Would you agree?