Ranger: Cult is unlikely but possible. it wouldn't mesh with the story well, and it's rare anyway.
Ranger: If you don't trust your ability to identify scum, how do you plan to scumhunt?
Lenglon: I don't trust myself with a Vig-kill because of how reactive I can be, which would result in a probable misfire with the death of a Townie. Not to mention that if anyone was watching my actions at the time, it may lead to a wasted lynch on me the next day. Speculation, but I don't trust myself with NKs against the Mafia. I plan to scum hunt as one normally would, ask questions and judge reactions, See whos playing defencesively and whos jumping on wild accusations, and don't fully trust anyone unless you know 100% you can.
Why do you seem to think I would not try scumhunt normally? Or at all if I understand the meaning of your question?
Tiruin: You are a cop with a confirmed Townie who trusts you but the rest of the town is getting ready to lynch them. Do you claim to try to save them, or use persuassion only to help with this. Lets say its day 3 and you were blocked night 2.
"C-cop? Oh, so did I confirm the townie? How did that townie get confirmed?
"...Trusts me in what way? If you mean I confirmed him on N1, then I'd let the lynch go, but then check on what everyone else was doing to the soul and analyze from then on."
Tiruin tilts her head to the side, pondering. "This is strange, Lady Cado, like you wish to know detailed specifics. What are you trying to find out here?"
Leafsnail: Everytime I claim early, I get lynched. So no, I will not claim day 1 no matter my role or alignment because I will get killed for WIFOM... and no one start bugging me about that please, I get it, It was stupid. Who do you believe would be the three deadliest Mafia members together and why?
"Can you give your own analysis on what early claims did, on the first day, in that context of getting lynched to us? What have you learned? Why is it WIFOM? Why 'three deadliest'?"
You inspected them Night 1 yes, and they trust you due to how you've played and acted. The details are more due to people asking for more details when I've asked the question in a more general form. (You are a cop and confirmed a townie Night 1. The town suspects them and is leading a lynch against them. Do you try to save him and in what way?)
What I am trying to do is judge your answers to these questions, and If I find something fishy, I will pursue it to the best of my ability to see if my suspicions turn up anything. If they do, i'll dig deeper. If they don't, i'll keep an eye out for other things that pop out as strange as I switch over to others.
I claimed cop day 1 in a BM. I had three votes on me and knew I was about to have a lynch case built on me from the way I was being questioned. I hoped to try and send everyone else against someone who I felt was acting scummy. As the discussion went, most thought I was lying, then saw that if the "real cop" just claimed right then, one less scum to deal with. So a few believed me. Then, slowly the votes came back against me for creating a plethora of WIFOM due to forcing the Jailer to have to protect me, so I was lynched. I have had another Bad claim experience as Third-party in Toon Mafia 7, and from those, I'd rather not claim until absolutely necissary. ie: during mass claim time, or when It could reliably shift the votes correctly. I have learned to not jump to conclusions about claiming, and think more about it... though I was correct about a lynch case coming at me in the BM
I picked three deadliest because I wish to see who leafsnail believes would be the three players he would find most dangerous as a mafia team. I also think three is a good starting point for how many mafia members we may be trying to find.
You always seem to leave me with a lot to answer Tiruin, so lets see If I can do the same. If you were the doctor, how would you pick your target during the night? How about as a tracker? And the Mafia Rolecop as well? And who do you believe is the strongest player as town in this game?
Lenglon: I would prefer a protect over a vig-kill due to how terrible my luck is, and the guilt that would seep into my posts if I used it and killed a townie.
Why would you feel guilty for killing a town?
Do you feel similarly guilty when you mislynch somebody?
I would feel guilty for it due to harming the town with my action, and by extension, helping the Mafia team. I do as well when I mislynch someone, though not as much due to them making the mistakes that lead to their lynch, as well as the support of several players in this leading to their lynch.
Princess Cado
NQT: What would be your preferred third party role, and do you believe there will be an abundance of them similar to Toon Mafia 7, or a couple scattered through the group?
My prefered 3rd party role would be jester or martyr as I always lose so it might be nice to win in losing for once. We have no way of telling how abundant 3rd party roles are until the game properly gets underway. It's nice to get the ball rolling with conversation, but do you think my answer has brought you any closer to discovering the wicked princesses?
NQT: An unusual question can show a slip up early on if someone answers it without thought. It was partially to start the conversation going, but an early slip is always useful in the RVS stage. Your answer shows the norm I would expect... minus some kind of put down towards me for a strange question, so I will continue to question you on more conventional things.
Who would you prefer to have on your scum team? What would be your preferred scum team to go against as town?
Rangercado, "What makes an upstart like yourself think she's worthy of our prince?
Ottofar: I've learned from my mistakes slowly, and better to learn than to think you know everything. But what makes you believe that I would be worse than anyone else? What have you seen previously that makes you think I can't, or haven't learned?
Ranger:
Toaster: [/b]What would be your preferred town Power in this game? How about Mafia as well?
Town... it's been a while since I've rolled cop. That'd be a nice one to have for a change. As scum, I favor the confusion-sowing powers- redirects and the like.
Would you rather have a confirmed townie or confirmed scum to deal with? Also, why ask about cults?
Toaster: I would rather have a confirmed Townie, for the simple reason that I have someone whos opinion I can see is not filled with ill intent and is honest. Knowing my allies seems a better plan to me unless i'm at deaths door, then a confirmed scum player would be more useful as a parting word.
I asked about cults to get a conversation going and to judge reactions to an unorthodox question this early in the game. Finding a strange answer to that question was unlikely, but better to try and see where it gets you than not.