NQT, because of how he frequently gets power roles/third party.
Ah, you believe in a sort of cosmic luck. It is true that in life I am the third-party, a loose cannon spouting loose canon; a maverick 90 degrees askew from the rest of civilisation. But really, there are probably better reasons to rolecop someone.
DUDE! You are an IC! YOU CANNOT DO THIS! If you are going to give advice you need to GIVE advice. Come on man. You're better than this.
Nerjin, I note that your first and only vote has been on DaveTheGrave. Do you think your first instinct was good and do you think you've adequately pressured other players?
[. . .]
The current lynch candidate by two points is DaveTheGrave. His main 'scum-tells' have been to act very defensively, not responding to questions and to vote without any accompanying reason or question. He has since answered some questions and given a handful of reads of other players. By the time Day 1 ends, each of us will have to weigh up whether his behaviour is more scummy than anyone other player. Are these conceivably the actions of a town or a scum player? This means continuing pressuring and questioning other players and following up when they give lousy responses.
Yes I feel that my read is accurate. He has not given a proper case on any of his suspects. While I'm sure he's trying [it's hard the first time] I feel that it isn't up to par with what we should expect as players. His reads have been along the lines of "I feel X is scum." with no real reasoning behind it and his reads are rather vague at best anyways. Also asking questions at this point doesn't really help.
We are out of the RVS stage. The RVS stage generally ends when players have begun forming decent reads and start pressuring specific players with things that they have already said and NOT with what they plan to do later on. Plus there's the fact that he bandwagoned so... Yeah I feel confident in my vote.
I must ask: You are aware that you can question a player without switching your vote to them right? It's easy. Just ask the question. Don't red there name. I'm not sure if you knew this. We're getting close to day-end so why don't you vote for the person you feel is scummiest instead of tossing your vote at me for "pressure" that doesn't really need applied.
Imperial: Your scum, its N2, and you think youve killed the cop. Whats your next step?
Chink: You are a cop, its N3, theres four people left. All of which are showing signs of aggression towards you. How do you proceed?
[. . .]
My suspicions are that Imperial and Griffin are scum buddies, since I'm probably going to be lynched anyway, I thought Id put that out there.
When you are NK'ed your role is revealed the start of the next day.
Also your reads need to be more than that: WHY do you think they are scum-buddies?
A note towards imperial. Though he has yet to accuse me of being scum, he still sees it fit to vote for me. Obviously he has no reason to vote for anyone because...HE IS THE SCUM. Dun dun dun....
Unvote griffin, vote Imperial
Not enough of a reason. OMGUSing doesn't help us at this point. Please state more as to why he is scum. Aside from that I'm pretty sure that he thinks you're scum because he's said it.
He dodged several questions after the game began, is only reacting to me voting him, and is only condemning himself.
He screwed up and tried to build a case against me.
On a second note, I voted for you before you voted for me. So how does that make sense?
Are... Are you... YOU LITERALLY ADMIT THIS? You never admit to an OMGUS! You also never OMGUS at all! Alright Dave, I'm pretty sure you're scum. Whether you are or aren't I want you to try again in the next BM okay? You have potential. I can see that BUT YOU NEED PRACTICE! Read some of the "Great Games" of the forum and try to learn from them. Okay?
Nerjin: Which players do you think are the scum, and why?
Well for now I only see one. DaveTheGrave.
He's avoided questions, OMGUSed, bandwagoned, and has not voice any of his 'cases' very well. A player should NEVER have to be reminded as many times as he has to answer questions. Especially when they are directly quoted back at him. He is either scum or poor town. Again I hate to be rude. I hope he tries again in the next BM as I think he will learn a lot from another go. But for now he's a liability at best and scum at worst. He needs to be eliminated. Sink-or-Swim style teaching needs to being.
Author
Topic: BM XLII - Game Over: Mafia Win! (Read 76495 times)