This is complicated, I'll try to keep all of these separate.
I snagged Starpoint Gemini 2 on the Steam freebie giveaway a few days ago. I'm hopelessly addicted to space choose your own games, so I love the game.
For the most part. Except for these:
No Campaign for the Wicked
So you're the "Goody Two Shoes" by default. They control the most interconnected space, which is fine. But there's a karma meter that lets you push into "Outlaw" mode, so you can do what you want coz a pirate is free. But there's not much of a story to it, despite a lot of hooks being set up in the main campaign that the bad guys are actually incredibly desperate because reasons and you actually hook up with some of them for a brief time.
But nah, never addressed. In fact, for most of the game's life you couldn't even ally with the big bads, leaving a third of the map (including starbases and planets) completely inaccessible to you. But that was patched out so you can visit those places now... If you can get past
Annoyance Mode
Being "evil" is hard. Not because you're outgunned and limited to certain parts of space, that's fine. But keeping your karma meter negative is difficult.
When you start out, the Good Guys are neutral and the bad guys hate you. Do a few naughty things, and the Good Guys start to hate you... but the bad guys STILL HATE YOU. You must kick this many puppies to proceed. Once you do get access to more Outlaw areas...
There's a faction that always hangs out in Outlaw space, that will always attack you regardless of karma. They're EEEEVIL so defending yourself gets positive karma. You have no choice but to defend yourself, so your karma meter is climbing if you don't just avoid them.... but you can't avoid them, they're fucking everywhere.
The EEEEVILest factions don't trust you until your karma gets really low. But killing them raises your karma. They ALSO hang out with the rest of the bad guys, but will single you out constantly and none of your other groups will help.
They Just Didn't Care
Oh and the good guys keep offering you Freelance work, even if they hate you. Pick the wrong mission, and you get more positive karma. This actually includes... some smuggling work, for some reason. I guess you're delivering drugs and knives For Great Justice.
Also for some reason, your assassination targets WAY WAY WAY outclass you as an Outlaw. Got a frigate? Cool. Go kill two frigates, a cruiser, and a dreadnought at the same time.
Balance, lol?
Still, the control scheme is amazing for keys + mouse, and I really like most of the game in spite of all this. Just needed a whinge.