Tiruin:PFP
Speaking in brevity.Tiruin:
How isn't he? I don't see how he could've missed the cheesy fact that 3 people are misinforming, while the rest are searching to be informed. Or 4..forgot how many spies were there. Have to check on that note later.
What? The people that responded aren't going to tell him that they're misinforming. How would he know they gave him an untrue answer.
So… What’s your point? You’re obviously saying something about Tiruin but I can’t for the life of me figure it out. Are you saying she’s a spy because she brought up that YOU didn’t explain how GriffDay wasn’t taking into account that spies would try to mess with the poll. You seem awfully intent on implicating people with small evidence kiddo.
The bolded part is what I'm talking about when I say she's trying too hard to appear townie.
Obvious overstatement is obvious.
You address someone else prodding the notion and not my own? Then jump to the horrible PoV of 'too hard to appear townie'?
My sheepy sheep. That's quite an accusation for one who doesn't even talk to the accused. I don't see a logical rebel doing that.
What? I did address it to you. Right
here. Nerjin just didn't quote that part.
TWS's slip is total [CARP] in the way that he begins and ends addressing everyone else except the person prodding him about it--the very same person he's accusing.
How am I accusing Nerjin?
His logic is fallible--'trying to get a more experienced member with more experience on the team instead of him' directly goes against what he said earlier, one point being that he didn't expound on the point and instead gave another, different point.
That's not contradicting at all. In the first link I say Remuthra may have been trying to get Dariush onto the team instead of himself. In the second one I'm pointing out to Nerjin that I said "instead" instead of "with". Where do you see a contradiction?
From a total switch of 'O Remuthra may not be scum' to a definitive hypothetical statement.
"Definitive hypothetical"? It's hypothetical. It may not be true. And anyway, it's not like I'm saying this is definitely how it was. I'm giving ideas again.
Why else would Remuthra try to get off the mission if there were no other scum on it?
'Why else'?
> Conclusion and asking for other reasons.
Uh, yeah. I'm asking people if they have any other reasons, because if they don't, it would tend to back up my theory, right?
So far I'm thinking: Myself, Griffinpup, Griffionday and one of you, Tiruin, and Dariush. I'm not sure who yet. Probably not Dariush.
> Redeeming factors of the last member.
I'm understanding him more now. I'd like him to post now, though.
> Why yourself.
Really? Because I'm a rebel.
> Why Griffionday.
Already said.
> Why griffinpup.
Already said.
> Why not Lenglon.
Remuthra's actions, giving up, etc.
> Why not Nerjin.
Nerjin was the "you" in that sentence. (Sorry I'm being a little terse here, I'm trying to finish this post. But seriously, read back a few posts to see whether I gave reasons.)
Why am I taking so long to decide? I was about ready, then the whole communication business came out, and I'd like to see that resolved. Now I'm thinking about including Dariush and he's not around, and his next post will probably influence that decision quite a bit.
Oh, just realized I somehow missed
this post.
Nerjin:I'm going to smack you if you're talking about her forgetting how many spies there were. I mean it. I will look for you, find you, and smack you, then leave your house. That's not trying to appear too town y'know. That's forgetting how many people there are. If you condemn someone for something like that then I fear for the rest of us.
Thinking there might be four spies, even though in the last game there were 9 players and still 3 spies? Even though four spies would mean equal numbers of spies and rebels, which would be completely illogical?
I'm sorry I appear to have mis-spoke. Please say why you don't trust him. You mentioned him as a possibility [however remote] of being on your team so you NEED TO EXPLAIN! Sorry if I seem a bit rude about this point but you are the team LEADER. We need to see your thought process so that we can see if we can trust the team, not only because of who is on it, but who chose it.
You also mentioned me as a possible member. Why? What have I done to inspire confidence? What have I done to make your worried about sending me? Please explain your reads on the possible people you'd send.
I still feel like Dariush's D1 decisions were a bit strange. Also, he ignored
this post and has been lurking recently.
My reasons for you were process of elimination again. I had three people, needed a fourth. The three people I mentioned for that fourth position weren't ideal. You I have a pretty null read on still.
Did I miss anyone?
Lenglon:Sheep:Why Dariush over Nerjin? unless I've been misreading, you think Dariush is a spy, why would you include him?
I meant he'd be the last one of the three I'd put on the team. As in, I trust him least.
Sorry if I missed stuff. I'm tired, and I guess I'll just put out my pick now, since I feel like everyone(myself included) is getting a bit bored.
TheWetSheep
Griffinpup
Griffionday
Nerjin