You stated that it took twenty minutes to kill the worm
He didn't need to hold his breath for twenty minutes, it didn't take that long for the worm to be killed, thus giving him the chance to escape.
You never prompted Cheesecake to give you a turn, and if I remember right you have done that before. In fact, you DIDN'T UPDATE until you had everyone's turns EXCEPT Cheesecake's.
I never said he couldn't take an action, everyone including Cheesecake just assumed he was dead, which is what I guessed you would all assume, thus I was skipping his turn without describing what he was going through in order to create this feeling that he was dead, so that it would be a surprise when he emerged unscathed. And I was right.
All of these things made it pretty clear that he was dead.
You did assume he was killed. You did fall for my trick. I didn't save him, he was never in danger (sorta. one more turn and he would've been dead). It wasn't a miracle. I never brought him back from the dead. You're the only one who thinks so.
[I have no idea how this could possibly be made more clear. Every objection you have has been addressed.
The orc didn't instadie upon being eaten, due to biology of a worm and his being a tough orc. He
almost died and only lived because other players put forth effort to explain why it was possible to happen. As a good DM, Gun considered this, and decided that because the reasoning was logical and the timing was good, it served the purpose of the story to have the character live.
Now, maybe if he had said "The worm chews up the orc and has magical acid spit" then it'd be a plot-hole deus ex machina for him to be saved. But he didn't. Therefore, shooooooooooooooosh.]
In character:
I suddenly felt a headache, as though someone were arguing with the gods and the gods were getting tired of these shenanigans.
With this much meat, maybe there was something... hm. I decided to
look around for worm intestine I could tie into some sort of storage sack.
"Guys, quit talking to the artifacts of doom, and WHAT IN THE GODS NAME IS THAT THING!?"
Amended action:
flip the fuck out for a moment at the random voice from nowhere and the whole "speaking to the doom artifact" then
rig up intestine sack storage after rationalizing it as "I hate the gods
so much."