Michael: Well, think of it this way. We're kind of like a self-help forum, except it's a thread in the "off-topic" board, on a forum about something completely different. A good metaphor. But anyway we all have different answers, is the important thing.
Now this is quite a pickle. We have no confirmation, one way or another. We're soon to find out for sure, though.
We need to get to Tel Fyr ASAP. Then, we must find out the status of that note From here we have several possibilities:
1) The selfish way. We let her take it first. If PC's work the way we think they do, then she'll reload if she dies. If not, then she's dead and we're not. And we know she's not the Nerevarine. But Awesomicus might still be. If he is, then both Clover and us would both die from drinking.
2) The selfless way. We take it ourselves. If we're the Nerevarine, then we live no problem. If not, then we have to rely on a reset. But we know that's a very, very, very risky move. We could just wind up dead for good.
Considering that both of these might involve a reload, it's possible we might not see what was reset, and thus not have access to alternate hindsight. Considering what we know, I'd say Clover's the most likely candidate for Nerevarine, as she's followed the Main Quest the most. I'd say that we're the second most likely candidate. But as Awesomicus is still a candidate, and is a competent fighter, we should bring him.