I didn't post the rolls? Crap, I *am* distracted. Here you go, so you know what I'm working with (and congratulations, you didn't die and can win this in the next round!)
Bit more cleaning. Sorry.
Thales:
HOLY PUNCH: 18
SWORDSMITE: 21
(brief interlude of HAHA MY GOD IS AWESOME, SUCK IT, BITCHES)
ATTACK SERVITOR 2:
DEAD
Daethwin:
HEALBUFF: 24
WARBUFF: 15 - +3 to all
Jewel: Full Health
Rurail: Full Health
Thales: Full Health + 5 HP Bonus (Natural 20!)
Sylvari: Full Health
Daethwin: Full Health
Thales:
CHAAAAAAAAAAAAAARGE!: 23 (applies to next round)
Jewel:
YOU SHALL NOT PASS!: 19
ATTACK SERVITOR 4:
ATTACK (JEWEL): 12 (Nope!)
ATTACK (JEWEL): 19 vs 19; 13 vs Natural 1 (10 HP of Death damage; no degrade)
TURN INCORP: 21
Rurail
DEFEND: 15
SUPPORT/CONTINGENCY: 17 vs 17, 7 vs Natural 1 (Servitor 4 reincorporates; is HOLY SPEARED to death)
ATTACK SERVITOR 4:
DEAD!
MAGE SERVITOR 1:
TURN INCORP: 25
DEATH AOE: 22
Thales - 19 Death damage
Rurail - 15 Death damage
Jewel - 7 death damage
Sylvari - 5 death damage
Daeth - 2 death damage
0 damage to Servitors - IMMUNE
DEATH ARROW (THALES): 7 vs 10, 0 HP damage
Sylvari:
WILD SWING!: 13 (0 Damage)
DOUBLE SWING pt 1: Natural 20!
2x SWING pt 2: 22
Servitor 2: 15 HP Fire/Magic Damage
Servitor 3: 13 HP Fire/Magic Damage
MAGE SERVITOR 2:
TURN INCORP: 30 (Natural 20!)
DEBUFF AOE:
Sylvari: -2 to all
Daeth: NOPE!
Jewel: -3 to all
Rurail: -1 to all
Thales: -2 to all
MOTION: 10 vs 16
Jewel/Rurail:
HOLD THE LINE+CONTINGENCY: Combined 18 vs Natural 20
Mage Servitor 2:
DEATH TOUCH (Jewel): 7 HP Death damage
MAGE SERVITOR 3:
TURN INCORP: 27
MOTION: 17 vs 4
DEATH TOUCH (DAETH): 11 vs Natural 1 - 10 HP Death damage, armor decay from Good to Average quality
Current damage/spent MP (subtract this from your totals)
Daeth: 12 HP damage, 18 MP spent
Sylvari: 5 HP damage, 5 MP spent
Thales: 14 HP damage, 20 MP spent
Jewel: 24 HP damage, 12 MP spent
Rurail: 15 HP damage, 9 MP spent
Surviving enemies:
B-1: Healthy
B-2: Nearly Dead
B-3: Nearly Dead
EDIT: Basically, Jewel and Rurail *did* stop one Servitor; the problem is that it got lucky and got in a good hit. Natural 20's are sometimes terrible.
Also, ouch, Daeth, but the victor of the "take the damage like a champ" goes to Jewel.