@Shinigami_KingIf you really had given up on the scumteam and tried to help the Town win, that would make you the worst player to have in any Mafia game ever.
Not humility, it's a title I earned. Just want to make sure everyone knows the sort of
Scum-fucker person they're playing with. That and I'm the worst player to have in any mafia game ever... But onto your points:
I accuse your humble statements of a case of RIA. And I accuse you of being scum! Now, seeing as lenglon just presented a reasonable and straightforward case on Deathsword I would like you to go over every point in her list and address it fully. Just try to defend your scum buddy. If you can't retaliate to her case then I am assuming that you are voting Lenglon for no strong reason either.
1. He's not my scum-buddy. I'm not sure if he's scum or whatever but I know I'm not so just wanting to address that first.
2. Lack of strength regarding her case doesn't make mine weaker. But I will indulge you.
[1]Deathsword is scum.
[2] Deathsword has not asked a single question since his first post of the game, during the very start of the RVS phase.
[3] Deathsword voted on a target of opportunity, using other people's arguments, and none of his own, including old nonsensical ones.
[4] Deathsword is not answering all the questions asked of him.
[5] Deathsword has used borderline lurking behavior in the past to hide when he is scum.
[6] Deathsword is currently using borderline lurking behavior.
[7] Deathsword has posted six times, three of those contain no content, one is an opening RVS post.
[8] Deathsword has taken quotes out of context.
[9] Deathsword set off my instincts on a large scale, and I should trust my instincts.
[A] Deathsword also is a horrible person, because he directly advocated that I stand by when I see someone being abused and do absolutely nothing. but this is not evidence that he is scum, just that I never, ever, want to have him as a neighbor.
1. Deatsword is Scum: I'm not sure, maybe he is. Although I disagree considering that of the "6" posts he's to have done "2" of them are
2. Deathsword has not asked questions: Hm... That's a very good point. I hadn't actually noticed. Maybe he is lurking like crazy. He has asked questions but she mentions this... However that's not good enough on it's own considering that later:
3. Deathsword Voted. . . Old Arguments: Null-tell as using others cases to bolster your own or when you honestly just don't have anything to add isn't scummy to me. Others would disagree but...
4. Deathsword not answering questions: He's answered questions relatively well. He has two large posts where he responds rather well and he mentions how he can't post as often as some other people. 2/6 or 1/3 is a pretty good number even if he is lurking he is up-front about it at the very least.
5. Deathsword Lurks as Scum: Meta-tell that I can't prove one way or the other.
6. Deathsword is lurking: Nothing borderline about it kiddo he's lurking pretty hard. Though as I've said before he mentions this and he has 1/3 good posts. Not sure about YOUR ration though.
7. Deathsword lacks posts and is being lurk-y: Yeah just went through that and it's pretty true. Except that, again, he's relatively good for content/post ratio. I wish he posted more but when he does he's pretty good about it.
8. Deathsword Quotes out of Context: Uh, could you post links to these areas Lenglon? I've looked and I didn't see these instances.
9. Instincts: Don't mean anything to me.
A. This has nothing to do with the game. Please let's not drag that up. A forum game insult and a true insult are differing things.
B. THERE'S the content I'm looking for. Easy to read, easy to respond to, and relatively strong. That being said I don't think that some of your points hold up.