Okami No Rei:
swordsmith04
If I was a vig and didn't have any idea who the remaining scum were, and there was enough information to be gained from it whether the player flipped scum or town, then yes, I would. This is assuming most or all of the town is stuck, not just myself.
Could you provide an example situation where you think this would be the case?
Admittedly, in a scenario where town has few or no leads the potential benefit of a town-flip is small. A confirmed townie does mean that everyone can compare their reads to the known townie's, and we can examine how that townie interacted with the others. Not worth the vig-kill by itself. The chance of hitting scum instead is the main reason I might do it, not only for actually killing the scum but giving us a chance to root out their scumbuddy, too, if they're still in play. I should probably have been less definitive about it, really. More like 'I (probably) would'. The chance of me hitting scum and getting us back on track with one or more possible targets is probably better than scum slipping up at that stage, since up until that point the entire town has been fooled.
borno:
Griffionday - Town
RangerCado - Null, leaning towards town. Looks to be taking cues from Griffionday
borno - Null leaning scum.
Imperial Guardsman - Scum
Okami No Rei - Null, leaning slightly scum. Conveniently missed most of D1 despite having logged on to Bay12 at least once without posting in the thread during that time.
Spectr - Null. Leaning scum
for lurking. On rereading, they didn't seem to be lurking all that much. Their posts have little to no content, though, so I'll keep my reading as is.
Nerjin - IC; Null until proven otherwise. Leaning slight town.
DeathSword - IC; Null until proven otherwise. Leaning slight town.
Imperial Guardsman:You show up for the game a day late and provide no excuse,
posting five times in a row and making your response look larger than it actually was. Your answers are short, mostly unexplained, and inadequate. Your only attempt at RVS is to question an IC on how a scum would try to appear town. Despite being asked to clarify one of your answers, you then disappear for three days, and when you show up
again you ignore the clarification request and my question. I and DeathSword immediately prompt you for answers and Okami No Rei asks you a third question, and you still haven't answered us yet, over a day later. Despite last being active on the forums less than an hour before this post. Counting your pentuple (Is this even a word? Bah, you all know what I mean.) posting as one post, you have posted in this thread exactly twice since the game began, five days ago. Explain to me why we shouldn't lynch you right now, scum?
Author
Topic: BM XL: Miner's Mafia (Scumteam Wins!) (Read 45449 times)