Made some interesting findings, check the below spoilers.
ENEMY NAME | WEAPON ADVANTAGE / PERSONAL SKILL? | DAMAGE | DAMAGE W/ PURE WATER | DOUBLE? | TOTAL | TOTAL W/ PURE WATER | THEIR HIT CHANCE | THEIR HIT CHANCE W/ WEAPON TRIANGLE |
Sentinel | Yes | 14 | - | No | 14 | - | Auto | 68 |
Elite Axeman | Yes | 17 | - | No | 17 | - | 59 | 44 |
Swordmaster | No | 8 | - | Yes | 16 | - | 77 | - |
Sergeant | No | 12 | - | No | 12 | - | 83 | - |
Bishop | ?Personal Skill (Mages)? | 25 | 15 | No | 25 | 15 | 88 | 78 |
Druid | ?Personal Skill (Mages)? | 31 | 21 | No | 31 | 21 | Fen: 70 | Hell: 60 | Fen: 60 | Hell: 50 |
Fire Sage | Personal Skill (Mages) | 28 | 18 | No | 28 | 18 | 91 | 81 |
Elite Sentry | No | 10 | - | No | 10 | - | 89 | - |
ENEMY NAME | WEAPON ADVANTAGE? | DAMAGE | DAMAGE W/ PURE WATER | DOUBLE? | TOTAL | TOTAL W/ PURE WATER |
Sentinel | Yes | 8 | - | Yes | 16 | - |
Elite Axeman | No | 12 | - | Yes | 24 | - |
Swordmaster | Yes | 1 | - | Yes | 2 | - |
Sergeant | Yes | 5 | - | Yes | 10 | - |
Bishop | No | 27 | 17 | Yes | 54 | 34 |
Druid | No | 33 | 23 | No | 33 | 23 |
Fire Sage | No | 25 | 15 | Yes | 50 | 30 |
Elite Sentry | No | 4 | - | Yes | 8 | - |
Valor's better than Sal at plugging up that hole in all cases he isn't up against another sword. So yeah, congrats BMM, you are most likely taking Sal's place in plan A and taking pure water yourself. I guess this proves that, yes, speed is really,
really important. In pretty much everything.
Here's the suggested first plan actions: Seyena throws a javelin at the swordmaster and moves south one. Valor takes Seyena's pure water, moves north one, swaps to his crit sword and uses the pure water. Sal assaults the sword master with is deadly lance and moves to where Seyena was. He'll most likely get downed, but it won't be as terrible and will actually help sturdy the wall.
If we still want to corpse wall: Seyena is the noncommittal action this time, so as to whether her javelin kills the sword master is the key to if this plan will work.
While mages were the biggest and most prevalent problem with the old plan, in this one it's just the sword master (because of crits) and the Druids (Hell). Thing is, with
Sal in the way, the sword master can't reach Valor. In order to get him down this time, they'd need to Hell Valor twice. Thing is, they got three chances to do so.
I feel this is some kinda of weird combo between the corpse wall and the defensive line, but that's probably because it is. So yeah, corpse wall is still the sure thing, but this time our fall back plan is much better than our old one. Enough so that I almost suggest it over the corpse wall (still a sure thing but only assured for this turn, I see Danya not standing for a few more turns with those archers around.), but either would be good.
The corpse wall could fail too because the druids could try to Hell Seyena enough to make her susceptible to the sage. Her Hail Mary skill makes it unlikely, but possible.
There use to be old, now pointless info here. Its gone now.