Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Captain Ford]

Tiruin: Small problem. You have more town reads than there are town players.

Also, are you asking me for my read on NQT? Or are you asking NQT what his reads are? Well, here's mine, anyway:

So NQT is the third one in my party. Based on what I've seen from him recently, and with that last post as a capstone, I'm putting him down as 99% rebel.

I posted a lot of material to explain that read. That's just the executive summary.

[Tiruin]

Tiruin: Small problem. You have more town reads than there are town players.

PFP
Yeah, that's what I've been trying to get - when I say town, its usually vague. The third scum is hidden from my view as of the moment (questions later on because no reread yet).

[Captain Ford]

It's not like I have any better idea. I'm just kind of avoiding the big pileup of maybe-spies for later.

By the way, Leafsnail's kind of right about the time we've got. The OP doesn't say anything about 24 hours. What it does say is that the entire planning phase, from team proposal to voting on it is supposed to last about three days.

Obviously, that number's very flexible.

[GlyphGryph]

Vote Count for the proposed team:
Captain Ford
ToonyMan
notquitethere
Nerjin

Up
notquitethere
Toonyman
Tiruin
zombie urist

Down
Dariush
Nerjin
Toaster
leafsnail
Captain Ford

The Team has been rejected. Leafsnail is now the new team leader.

[Dariush]

There's been like 90 posts over the last two days, and like hell I'm going to read through all of them.

ZU, explain your upvote.
Ford, explain your downvote.

[Toaster]

Down
Captain Ford

lolwut


ZU:

There's no way I'm voting up a team with both Nerjin and NQT.

Up
zombie urist

O RLY?



(So yeah, what Dariush said, basically.)

[Leafsnail]

Maybe GlyphGryph got them mixed up?  I mean one person doing it could be a mafia trick but why would two people do it in opposite directions??

[GlyphGryph]

I can confirm that both votes are correct.

[notquitethere]

This is highly suspect. Did the scum team uniformly upvote or downvote this team? (Or could the scum have competently organised a system for voting at odds to one another?)

I need to go have another look over the results of the other votes, but my intuition at the moment is that ZU and Tiruin could be scum upvoting a team with one scum on it, possibly Toonyman. This is idle speculation at the moment, so I'm going to go do some analysis...

Best case of course is that this is a town team and scum all downvoted it.

[Tiruin]

This is highly suspect. Did the scum team uniformly upvote or downvote this team? (Or could the scum have competently organised a system for voting at odds to one another?)

I need to go have another look over the results of the other votes, but my intuition at the moment is that ZU and Tiruin could be scum upvoting a team with one scum on it, possibly Toonyman. This is idle speculation at the moment, so I'm going to go do some analysis...

Best case of course is that this is a town team and scum all downvoted it.

Explain your intuitive read on me and ZU. Explain who you think is scum who downvoted it. Why do you think the team is 'town'.

And...uniformly? What are you getting at?

[Dariush]

Now that I think about it, it's quite likely that ZU pushed for a team with a spy in direct contradiction to his earlier words so that the game would be over before someone is able to do anything about it. I think I saw some speculation by someone that there were five upvotes (but, like I said, like hell I'm going to go digging through there).

To recap, my current bet on the scumteam is ZU, Tiruin and Nerjin and I'll downvote any team with either of them.

[Toaster]

Dariush:  Why do you think Scum Nerjin would downvote a team he was on?

[Tiruin]

Dariush:  Why do you think Scum Nerjin would downvote a team he was on?

In addition to that, judging by how you outed me, why do you think a spy would be defending a fellow spy in such an illogical fashion? A reasonable answer is preferable.

[zombie urist]

Yeah I knew that post would fuck me over right as I made it. I'll get a better post + answers to Tiruin hopefully by tomorrow, since I anticipate today being really busy.

[Toaster]

Dariush:  Why do you think Scum Nerjin would downvote a team he was on?

In addition to that, judging by how you outed me, why do you think a spy would be defending a fellow spy in such an illogical fashion? A reasonable answer is preferable.

I'm not sure I follow- who exactly are you referring to?