Between 0 and 1 scum:
ToonyMan
NQT
Nerjin
This part is incorrect. It's 0 to 2 scum, because Leafsnail could have been the only spy in both the other groups. This invalidates most of the logic in the rest of your post.
Ford: What say you? I'm interested in hearing your thoughts.
I'm all over the place right now. The only thing I'm certain about right now is that ToonyMan is going on my team. After that, it's a crapshoot.
If I choose to believe Leafsnail, that gives me a lot of valuable information to work with -- but if I'm going to choose to believe him, then there's no point in not putting him on the team. The only reason I was okay with having him on both teams was because I thought he was town enough to eliminate as a suspect, and most everyone else seemed to feel the same way. If that isn't still the case, then I (we) just wasted a mission.
Actually, now that I think about it, everyone on this mission was someone I thought was town. That was the whole point, really.
On another note:
My trust on Leafsnail has dropped quite a bit.
Why? What did he do that shook your trust in him?
Tiruin, you too:
Tiruin: So who do you think is the most likely scum team?
Leafsnail - confirmed scum. I'm not assuming there were any buddies brought in who performed a lay low action. Anything else is still up for verification.
Why are you so certain? What has changed to make you think Leafsnail was scum, specifically?
From my perspective, nothing has changed to make me suspect Leafsnail any more than last week, and that's because I was already looking ahead to after the mission. At some point I realized that if the mission succeeded, then the game was basically over (I'd send the same team again, and then on mission 4 we could add anybody and still win it). I didn't point this out before the mission, because I didn't want to discourage spies from laying low -- a win is a win, after all.
However -- I do feel like LS is doing the same thing NQT is doing, if more subtly -- listing information without applying pressure for a read. It's not bad information, but he makes no effort to refine it by questioning people. In the absence of the all the emotion I felt when I voted a few days ago, the subtle signs I've been picking up from Leafsnail all along really stand out.
If Leafsnail is a spy, it stands to reason that Tiruin isn't. He likely wouldn't have picked another spy for his own team. On top of that, Tiruin is making a primitive logical mistake that he wouldn't be making if they were both spies -- and it has to do with the fact there was only one sabotage on the first mission.
...so I'm contemplating sending Tiruin on the mission.
Toony: As the person I have the strongest read on, I'm really interested in knowing who you would send.
Author
Topic: Viva la Revolucion! Game Over, man, Game over! (Read 133967 times)