Bay 12 Games Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  
Pages: 1 ... 25 26 [27] 28 29 ... 40

Author Topic: The Hobbit  (Read 55464 times)

Helgoland

  • Bay Watcher
  • No man is an island.
    • View Profile
Re: The Hobbit
« Reply #390 on: December 19, 2013, 08:40:33 pm »

That was one part I really missed: Them running out of water and Bompur sleeping because of that river, prompting them to go seek out the elves. Would've made for some nice pictures, too.
Logged
The Bay12 postcard club
Arguably he's already a progressive, just one in the style of an enlightened Kaiser.
I'm going to do the smart thing here and disengage. This isn't a hill I paticularly care to die on.

Bauglir

  • Bay Watcher
  • Let us make Good
    • View Profile
Re: The Hobbit
« Reply #391 on: December 19, 2013, 08:50:51 pm »

I am deeply confused. How could they possibly make this movie and not include the Mirkwood starvation scenes? I mean, I could understand (and object) if they downplayed them or something, but it doesn't make sense to leave them out entirely.
Logged
In the days when Sussman was a novice, Minsky once came to him as he sat hacking at the PDP-6.
“What are you doing?”, asked Minsky. “I am training a randomly wired neural net to play Tic-Tac-Toe” Sussman replied. “Why is the net wired randomly?”, asked Minsky. “I do not want it to have any preconceptions of how to play”, Sussman said.
Minsky then shut his eyes. “Why do you close your eyes?”, Sussman asked his teacher.
“So that the room will be empty.”
At that moment, Sussman was enlightened.

SalmonGod

  • Bay Watcher
  • Nyarrr
    • View Profile
Re: The Hobbit
« Reply #392 on: December 19, 2013, 09:58:11 pm »

Because some things just don't translate well to film format, you know?
Logged
In the land of twilight, under the moon
We dance for the idiots
As the end will come so soon
In the land of twilight

Maybe people should love for the sake of loving, and not with all of these optimization conditions.

Bauglir

  • Bay Watcher
  • Let us make Good
    • View Profile
Re: The Hobbit
« Reply #393 on: December 19, 2013, 11:23:02 pm »

>________________>

I'll admit, I make that claim pretty frequently, but usually in the context of an omission, alteration, or addition that serves to further some storytelling goal or take advantage of the new medium to convey something that was done differently of necessity in the original. But that arc is the defining moment of "We're not that Heroic" in the middle segment of the book. It should've been the centerpiece of the movie once all the premises established by the first movie and the overall trilogy structure are accepted.

I mean, I am not that upset about it because it's a departure from the book, but because the book already provided the perfect route to progress what the first movie was doing, and they've apparently ignored it. I really need to find time to watch this, because it sounds like they've taken an absurdly sharp turn away from the direction they established in the first movie, and that is what bugs me. Adaptation is fine with me, it's fucking it up so that your version is alarmingly inconsistent in addition to being unfaithful that gets to me.

I expect the trilogy to be different from the book in a lot of ways, but I don't expect it to create narrative discontinuities with itself.
Logged
In the days when Sussman was a novice, Minsky once came to him as he sat hacking at the PDP-6.
“What are you doing?”, asked Minsky. “I am training a randomly wired neural net to play Tic-Tac-Toe” Sussman replied. “Why is the net wired randomly?”, asked Minsky. “I do not want it to have any preconceptions of how to play”, Sussman said.
Minsky then shut his eyes. “Why do you close your eyes?”, Sussman asked his teacher.
“So that the room will be empty.”
At that moment, Sussman was enlightened.

Helgoland

  • Bay Watcher
  • No man is an island.
    • View Profile
Re: The Hobbit
« Reply #394 on: December 20, 2013, 10:05:20 am »

Don't get too upset - it's a good movie! Just not the one you'd expect!
« Last Edit: December 20, 2013, 11:06:56 pm by Helgoland »
Logged
The Bay12 postcard club
Arguably he's already a progressive, just one in the style of an enlightened Kaiser.
I'm going to do the smart thing here and disengage. This isn't a hill I paticularly care to die on.

Tiruin

  • Bay Watcher
  • Life is too short for worries
    • View Profile
Re: The Hobbit
« Reply #395 on: December 20, 2013, 10:33:31 am »

Because some things just don't translate well to film format, you know?
I really doubt that.
Like how they...clipped out the whole attack on the Shire representing Saruman's real death instead of gravity..and all other implications of that sort, to pull back LotR.
Logged

nenjin

  • Bay Watcher
  • Inscrubtable Exhortations of the Soul
    • View Profile
Re: The Hobbit
« Reply #396 on: December 20, 2013, 11:02:16 am »

In the books, the dwarves were kind of reckless dumbasses, which is why Bilbo ends up becoming a hero. Because he has to cover for them.

It seems like in the movies though, they wanted the dwarves to be kinda main characters, in the sense they could carry the story without Bilbo. It's that kind of narrative tinkering that makes me not really want to see this. For me, the dwarves being angry, quick to act but short of thought is what kind of defined the book and how the story unfolded. It's also why Bilbo had any room to grow as a character, because he wasn't surrounded by competent charcters.
Logged
Cautivo del Milagro seamos, Penitente.
Quote from: Viktor Frankl
When we are no longer able to change a situation, we are challenged to change ourselves.
Quote from: Sindain
Its kinda silly to complain that a friendly NPC isn't a well designed boss fight.
Quote from: Eric Blank
How will I cheese now assholes?
Quote from: MrRoboto75
Always spaghetti, never forghetti

SalmonGod

  • Bay Watcher
  • Nyarrr
    • View Profile
Re: The Hobbit
« Reply #397 on: December 20, 2013, 12:33:51 pm »

Because some things just don't translate well to film format, you know?
I really doubt that.
Like how they...clipped out the whole attack on the Shire representing Saruman's real death instead of gravity..and all other implications of that sort, to pull back LotR.

I was being sarcastic :P

Most of the time, I really hate this excuse, because it's completely non-applicable to the complaints that are being made.  I understand that sometimes different formats have to use different methods to portray the same thing.  That's fine, so long as the the same thing is being portrayed in the end.  If you're changing core elements of the story, you can no longer peg that on format differences.  And a lot of the time, the argument is something more like "that's fine for a book, but it wouldn't made a good movie" or "a reading audience may relate to this, but most movie-goers wouldn't".  And if that's the case, I'd rather it not be adapted at all, because there's a strong tendency for movie adaptations to culturally supercede the books they're based on.  For something like Tolkien, that's a horrible fucking shame.  It really feels like something is being lost.
Logged
In the land of twilight, under the moon
We dance for the idiots
As the end will come so soon
In the land of twilight

Maybe people should love for the sake of loving, and not with all of these optimization conditions.

WillowLuman

  • Bay Watcher
  • They/Them Life is weird
    • View Profile
Re: The Hobbit
« Reply #398 on: December 20, 2013, 12:38:04 pm »

Don't bring up the whole "sack of the shire" thing, though. That is a legitimate excuse. If they had included that in the ROTK movie, it would have wrecked the pacing. And likely felt a bit cheap.
Logged
Dwarf Souls: Prepare to Mine
Keep Me Safe - A Girl and Her Computer (Illustrated Game)
Darkest Garden - Illustrated game. - What mysteries lie in the abandoned dark?

Bauglir

  • Bay Watcher
  • Let us make Good
    • View Profile
Re: The Hobbit
« Reply #399 on: December 20, 2013, 12:44:06 pm »

@nenjin

See, that's certainly not true of the first movie. The Dwarves wanted to be the heroes, but they bumbled their way through everything. Bilbo actually may have gotten a bit of a boost in importance (as I recall, his role with the Trolls was expanded to include Gandalf's argument-incitement, for instance). There was an impression of "Gah, I don't want to be a hero, I just want to get this over with" that actually let him get things done when the Dwarves were too busy posturing.

So if they're abandoning that, then it's a problem within the movies' own structure.

I mean, it's a failure as an adaptation, but on top of that it's an internal narrative breakdown. It's not just "You did a bad job of portraying The Hobbit", it's "You did a bad job at being art".
Logged
In the days when Sussman was a novice, Minsky once came to him as he sat hacking at the PDP-6.
“What are you doing?”, asked Minsky. “I am training a randomly wired neural net to play Tic-Tac-Toe” Sussman replied. “Why is the net wired randomly?”, asked Minsky. “I do not want it to have any preconceptions of how to play”, Sussman said.
Minsky then shut his eyes. “Why do you close your eyes?”, Sussman asked his teacher.
“So that the room will be empty.”
At that moment, Sussman was enlightened.

Ultimuh

  • Bay Watcher
  • BOOM! Avatar gone! (for now)
    • View Profile
Re: The Hobbit
« Reply #400 on: December 20, 2013, 04:27:09 pm »

"You did a bad job at being art".
Can one really be bad at this concept called 'art'?
I mean.. Even if someone paints something which most might call bad, some might see it as a masterpiece.
Logged

Bauglir

  • Bay Watcher
  • Let us make Good
    • View Profile
Re: The Hobbit
« Reply #401 on: December 21, 2013, 01:02:52 am »

Fair enough. To whatever extent that one can call something bad at being art, then, it's that.
Logged
In the days when Sussman was a novice, Minsky once came to him as he sat hacking at the PDP-6.
“What are you doing?”, asked Minsky. “I am training a randomly wired neural net to play Tic-Tac-Toe” Sussman replied. “Why is the net wired randomly?”, asked Minsky. “I do not want it to have any preconceptions of how to play”, Sussman said.
Minsky then shut his eyes. “Why do you close your eyes?”, Sussman asked his teacher.
“So that the room will be empty.”
At that moment, Sussman was enlightened.

Vattic

  • Bay Watcher
  • bibo ergo sum
    • View Profile
Re: The Hobbit
« Reply #402 on: December 21, 2013, 11:16:11 pm »

It was a nice day out and I found it entertaining for what it was. Can't help feeling disappointed on Tolkien's behalf; It's not how he'd of wanted it.
Logged
6 out of 7 dwarves aren't Happy.
How To Generate Small Islands

kaijyuu

  • Bay Watcher
  • Hrm...
    • View Profile
Re: The Hobbit
« Reply #403 on: December 22, 2013, 01:19:51 am »

"You did a bad job at being art".
Can one really be bad at this concept called 'art'?
I mean.. Even if someone paints something which most might call bad, some might see it as a masterpiece.
Well you can still criticize things by determining whether they reached the goals they were shooting for. Sophistication in art comes from achieving what you set out to do, and if the films didn't do that, they failed.

Someone might still like them or whatever, and there's nothing wrong with that, but the criticism isn't invalidated either.
Logged
Quote from: Chesterton
For, in order that men should resist injustice, something more is necessary than that they should think injustice unpleasant. They must think injustice absurd; above all, they must think it startling. They must retain the violence of a virgin astonishment. When the pessimist looks at any infamy, it is to him, after all, only a repetition of the infamy of existence. But the optimist sees injustice as something discordant and unexpected, and it stings him into action.

Sensei

  • Bay Watcher
  • Haven't tried coffee crisps.
    • View Profile
Re: The Hobbit
« Reply #404 on: December 22, 2013, 02:05:55 am »

"You did a bad job at being art".
Can one really be bad at this concept called 'art'?
I mean.. Even if someone paints something which most might call bad, some might see it as a masterpiece.
Yes, and they still might but it's still bad.
Logged
Let's Play: Automation! Bay 12 Motor Company Buy the 1950 Urist Wagon for just $4500! Safety features optional.
The Bay 12 & Mates Discord Join now! Voice/text chat and play games with other Bay12'ers!
Add me on Steam: [DFC] Sensei
Pages: 1 ... 25 26 [27] 28 29 ... 40