MrCelt: This...Alright, I understand you're a newbie. However, even taking that into account, this is the single worst vote I have ever seen in any Mafia game. You hammered a guy with your entire reasoning being "What Hapah said." This, of course, almost immediately after saying that...well...you don't like the bandwagon on UI. Not just that, but that you actually disagree completely with the argument that you used to kill UI. Explain.
Note the lack of actual statement of suspicion, merely saying "ok, you're noob, but explain", basically giving him the "because I'm noob" explanation pretyped.
General thought: I'm actually leaning against MrCelt being a mafioso. His actions, while quite off-putting, were mostly incredibly stupid and dumb. He doesn't feel like someone getting any advice in a scumchat. MrCelt feels like a third party of some sort, most likely, with town less likely.
(Mind you, I also had a stronger noob-read than scum-read on MrCelt, but unlike me, he actually presents arguments
against MrCelt being mafia, then fails to follow up.)
I don't like how little of an idea I have about who Toaster would vote, but he's promising the chance to argue for/against it. The MrCelt lynch Dariush wants isn't something I'm convinced on, and that's guaranteed.
Toaster, I guess.
Note he goes for the only choice that has chances of MrCelt's survival, states he wants a chance for discussion and then completely ignores it when it comes, and that half-assed "I guess" vote of resignation.
Mr. Celt: Alright. Now that people are leaving RVS and people are throwing their thoughts on actual matters of importance around, please give us your thoughts on, well...anything going on in the game right now. Also, how many games of Mafia have you played in Bay 12 before?
and
MrCelt: Again, please give your opinion on pretty much anything going on in this game. RVS is over. It's been over for quite some time now.
... read very much like coaching. He probably was saying the same thing over scumchat and was frustrated by MrCelt's lurkiness, so he insisted on the main thread, again without ever stating suspicion or even a FoS.